73 Comments
User's avatar
INGRID C DURDEN's avatar

the 3 judges who also don't do their job should also be dismissed, just like the almost entire Congress. And probably most of the so called representatives as well

Pat Orsban's avatar

it is a shame we have 3 rabid rodents on SCOTUS, who are to stupid to know what a women is

Micheal Nash, Ph. D.'s avatar

Ask me my opinion of a senate that put her there

Pat Orsban's avatar

at the time, I don't think cocaine mitch could have stopped the rabid rodents,

the dims did create the nuclear option, and we did get 3 mostly conservative judges, using that,

however, I think I have an idea what your opinion is of the most useless group of repubs we have seen since 2017, 2018,

T.'s avatar

Mitch is feeding the rodents chinese cheese

(Was)

Red green's avatar

And 3 more that don't have the common sense to read, understand and legislate the Constitution as it is written. IMO, the Constitution is NOT an instrument for interpretation, political bias, or pressure.

It's the "interpretations" and there consequences that has brought America to it's knees.

Pat Orsban's avatar

absolutely, the founding fathers are way smarter than todays idiot politicians, and they wrote a USC to protect us from people, and "people" are just as evil and nasty and perverted as when the democrats owned slaves,

David Pare's avatar

Thanks for the explanation.

Next up: Citizens United. Corporations aren't people, but they sure can be psychopathic. "CNN: Brought to you by....Pfizer!"

David Poe's avatar

“Thousands of judicial decisions sustaining an agency’s rulemaking or adjudication as reasonable would be open to challenge, and that profound disruption is especially unwarranted because Congress could modify or overrule the Chevron framework at any time.” Prelogaar makes that sound like a bad thing. And don't forget the ATF.

Jean's avatar

I’ve done a quick and dirty read this opinion. My understanding is that it does shift responsibilies for law back to the Judiciary and the Congress . Reliance on Administrative agency interpretations should be very rare and are still subject to judiciary review. 

In these cases the lower courts relied on Chevron to rule that Agency interpretations were definitive. In that the Supreme Court has ruled that Chevron deference is inappropriate, these cases are now remanded for further consideration. So the issue of imposing the charges in question are still to be determined. 

We have a positive step forward, but it appears to me our concerns are still unresolved.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

Syllabus

LOPER BRIGHT ENTERPRISES ET AL. v. RAIMONDO,

SECRETARY OF COMMERCE, ET AL.

CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR

THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT

Held: The Administrative Procedure Act requires courts to exercise their independent judgment in deciding whether an agency has acted within its statutory authority, and courts may not defer to an agency interpretation of the law simply because a statute is ambiguous; Chevron is

overruled. Pp. 7–35.

(a) Article III of the Constitution assigns to the Federal Judiciary the responsibility and power to adjudicate “Cases” and “Controversies”—concrete disputes with consequences for the parties involved. The Framers appreciated that the laws judges would necessarily apply

in resolving those disputes would not always be clear, but envisioned

FYI - did copy out a listing of relevant discussions I can share

As always Thank You for helping us access relevant info

Jean's avatar

On reflection, one might conclude the lower Courts have (like the Supreme Court in Murthy) been using Chevron as a way of avoiding hot potatoes.

If Im right about the status of the Fishermen cases, one could conclude the folks we are concerned about need to file law suits.

in the course of my pursuits I learned the fishermen were represented by two nonprofits. They were funded by the Koch Foundation (Koch is anti reg). They might want to check to see if these nonprofits would take them on or recommend nonprofits that might.

Alan Davis (FlyoverAlinCT)'s avatar

I hope it leads to profound resignations, dismissals, and firings.

„He has erected a multitude of new offices and sent hither swarms of officers to harass our people and eat out their substance”.

Th. Jefferson - Declaration

Ana González's avatar

Praise 👏 God!!!

I think that the SCOTUS is on a roll right ✅️ now while the left is in meltdown mode over the "debate!"

Charlotte's avatar

I’m here to ask, can we please get our incandescent lightbulbs back? And, I intend to keep my gas stovetop. :)

Micheal Nash, Ph. D.'s avatar

And gas powered car

Barbara Lekowicz's avatar

Oh especially my gas powered car!!!

D D's avatar

Amazing that this ruling took forty years to overturn! More time than it takes for a person's hair to go gray.

Big E's avatar

This was massively important. Let the administrative state disruption begin!

Let’s hope this ruling will trickle down to state medical boards and health boards, pharmacies, doctors and others who pay “Chevron Deference” obeisance to captured agencies such as CDC, FDA, NIH, WHO, etc. Perhaps we also can use this ruling to break the vast censorship industrial complex; it’s not that big a stretch to rescind the attitude: “well, the xxx administration told us to censor this guy/gal/whatever, so we did.”

Thank you to those 6 justices who decided it’s high-court time to make the legislative branch do its own work. We cheered this SCOTUS victory resoundingly!

mule_ear's avatar

I think you are correct. It depends on the judiciary, though. I think most judges want to do as little as possible, so they liked Chevron deference -- that way they didn't have to interpret the law (do more work).

We don't realize how insidious this doctrine has been. The thousands, probably millions, of ways this practice has crept into governance. I can only hope that we will find out. It will depend both on good judges and brave people to challenge the edicts enacted by an overly intrusive/aggressive executive branch.

Regardless, it is a great step in the right direction.

Cary Cupka's avatar

My patriotic spirit is already breathing easier. The air seems less coercive all of a sudden. The first page of the sylabbus states that SCOTUS answered the question "whether Chevron ...should be overruled or clarified." The majority HELD: "Chevron is overruled."

BrianE's avatar

This is great news and is a bigger decision than roe v Wade! OSHA and other administrative organizations will have a lot of turmoil

T.'s avatar

More turmoil ?

How much can we stand?

Jean's avatar

Thank you! The part you've shared is delicious! That NIH, Fauci and the cattle industry issues are cited makes for Hugh satisfactions. The gas appliance and EV issues run against recent edicts from our Governor. A reason to newly discover a tiny light in the darkness! On reading and absorbing the rest of the details!

Bestess Always ♡♡♡0/¥¥7

Larry Alexander's avatar

First win in a long war with the Administrative State.

Louise Vogel's avatar

This is major significant good news. Major.

Joanne L Bachmann's avatar

To the Drs. Malone - Thank you for shining a light on this matter last Fall. And for calling attention to so many hidden agendas over the last four years.

In matters of governance, that which operates in the dark constitutes the greatest threat to the Republic and the Constitution. It is up to We the People to draw the line and stand our ground.

Your contribution to the Light continues to be invaluable.

Bruce Miller's avatar

Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagen, and Ketani Brown Jackson dissenting.....

As they were stirring the pot, keening "double double, toil and trouble, fire burn and cauldron bubble."

Bruce Miller's avatar

Me? Or the harridans? Or both?

Tom Daniel's avatar

WOW! INCREDIBLE! FANTASTIC! WONDER of WONDERS - but MANY days and YEARS Late by the Supreme Court; and NO way of undoing the incredible damage CHEVRON (wait! make that the freaking "Natural Resources Defense Council") did to "free enterprise" in America - in the name of "saving the planet"?

The "NRDC" is a so-called "Non-Profit" organization ( code word by Collective Leftists ) signifying "non capitalist" , i.e., money- grubbing and therefore pure and righteous.

NO one voted for the "NRDC" to make policy and laws that DIRECTLY affect the daily lives of millions of (supposedly) sovereign American citizens - from birth to death!

Note the Chief Executive Officer of the "NRDC" pulls down an annual salary of: $1,189,947 - that's One Million, One Hundred Eighty Nine Thousand Nine Hundred Forty Seven dollars per year. The "average" salary of (30) voting Board members at the "NRDC" is: $932,125 dollars per year

The entire "Non-Profit"(NGO) set up is a clever ploy by the Collective Left to "legally" be "tax-free" yet VERY lucrative for CEO's presidents, board members and consultants.

Charlotte's avatar

I’m half tempted to tweet that dude on X and ask him why does he think he deserves that salary or even that position.

Micheal Nash, Ph. D.'s avatar

Would probably have the same answer the school system superintendents do for theirs

Pat Orsban's avatar

and the sound of rabid democrat vermin could be heard thru out the land, as their perverted schemes to kill off the poor is once again thwarted by the rule of law

and man, democrats and other rabid vermin hate laws that stop their evil

it will be nice that the law can be used to stop rabid vermin from using their gestapo regulators to force child mutilation on a state, that passed a law stopping it, see also Tenn.