The Enemy Within: Tyler Robinson is Trantifa
Charlie Kirk's Assassin, Domestic Terrorism and Left Wing Violence
The opinions expressed below are my own, and do not represent those of the US Government, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, or the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices.
The day after the assassination of Christian youth leader Charlie Kirk, I made the case that it was necessary to wait for confirmation and additional information concerning the shooter and his motives. The recovered rifle and inscribed bullet casings seemed all too convenient, seemingly directing anger and blame towards certain left-wing subcultures. The needed information and confirmation are now available. This was not a lone wolf, this was a representative of a violent left wing subculture, a branch of the Antifa movement known as Trantifa or Transtifa. If the Turning Point USA organization represents youth reaching for the light and a healthy, positive future, Trantifa is its dark counterpoint. Both compete and are engaged in recruiting and influencing the belief structures of American youth. Corporate media and their leftist echo chamber are guilty of actively and repeatedly portraying Turning Point USA as “far right” and falsely linking this Christian organization to either Fascism or the Neo-Nazi movement. But this is psychological projection and a perversion of both truth and the historic record. Historically, Fascism has always come from the left.
I am confident that certain Democrat party Senators and their aides, as well as their left-leaning Corporate media allies, will be tempted to misconstrue my words. To be explicitly clear, I am now calling on the US Federal Government and its legal investigative, enforcement, and homeland security capabilities to respond in full force to a domestic terrorist threat. I am not calling for, and specifically condemn vigilante violence. This has to be done rigorously, methodically, properly, professionally, and legally.
Based on available information, it is reasonable to infer that a member of the violent leftist organization self-identifying as “Antifa” would consider the founding leader of Turning Point, Charlie Kirk, as a high-value target. Cutting-edge social media researchers and image data mining specialists are rapidly accumulating confirmatory data, but for those who can read the meaning, the inscribed bullet casings tell the story.
Quoting Utah Governor Cox:
The three unfired castings were etched with the following:
“Hey Fascist! Catch! with an up arrow, right arrow, and three down arrow symbols”
“Oh beta chow bela chow bela chow chow chow”
“If you read this, you are gay lamo”
The spent casing carried the following inscription:
“Notices. Bulges. OWO. What’s this?”
What do the Inscriptions Mean?
To translate and understand the significance of these etchings, I turned to a recent essay in the on-line publication “Freedom and Reason”, authored by Andrew Austin. Austin is on the faculty of Democracy and Justice Studies and Sociology at the University of Wisconsin—Green Bay. Besides teaching courses on freedom and social control, research methods, and social theory, he has published numerous articles, essays, and reviews in books, encyclopedias, journals, and newspapers. Austin is not some pop-up engagement farming Instagram influencer seeking clicks, likes, and follows. Jill has been following his Facebook page and posts for quite a while now.
Antifa is hostile to the very liberal values that underpin a free society—democratic republicanism, freedom of conscience, speech, press, association, and assembly. Its reality is street violence: militants attacking conservatives for exercising their rights to gather and speak. It is the harassment and intimidation of anyone who affirms the reality of the gender binary in the face of trans ideology. It is the left’s alliance with Islamism—clerical fascism—and the resurgence of antisemitism that energizes the movement. They hate the Enlightened West and everything it stands for. They seek anarchy. All this is promoted because it advances ends sought by transnational corporate power.
To drill down a bit on this, engravings on the bullet casings used by the shooter provide a window into the internal threat our Republic is facing, but one has to know what these engravings mean. The message on a fired casing read: “Notices. Bulges. OWO. What’s this?” Messages etched on other cases: “Hey fascist, catch!” “O bella ciao, bella ciao, bella ciao, ciao, ciao.” “If you read this, you’re gay, LMAO.”
The first line, a sexualized meme, is common in furry culture, which is a category of the trans movement. It’s used in the online gaming community. The second line is a common sentiment expressed by Antifa. Fists, rocks, bullets, whatever, that’s what fascists are supposed to catch. The third line is from a folk song adapted by Italian antifascists during the resistance during WWII. The fourth line is rather typical in the trans community, which is hostile to gays. This might strike the reader as odd. Aren’t they in an alliance together? According to corporate marketing, sure. But, actually, trans is antithetical to gay.
I want to say more about the gay slur, because this is not obvious to many at first blush. In the trans worldview, a man who likes other men is not a homosexual but a heterosexual woman trapped in a man’s body. You hear this from men who date trans women, which means they are gay, deny they are gay, by saying that trans women are women, which they obviously aren’t and cannot be. Homophobia is deeply embedded in trans ideology.
This bizarre idea goes back to the crackpot sexologist Magnus Hirschfeld, who “theorized” that homosexual men are really women trapped in male bodies. Working with Nazi doctor Erwin Gohrbandt, Hirschfeld developed vaginoplasty. Hirschfeld and Gohrbandt’s idea was to liberate men by removing their testicles, slitting their penises, and shoving what remains up into the abdominal cavity, creating a neovagina. Their victims would then pretend to be women and experience “trans joy.”
The idea was updated by another crackpot sexologist in the 1960s, Robert Stoller, who promoted the term “gender identity,” which became the central doctrine of radical gender ideology. This ideology is used by the medical industry to justify medical atrocities.
This is not just Antifa, but rather is a particularly perverted and virulent sect within Antifa that self-identifies as Trantifa or Transtifa. Malone.News published a deep and well-documented dive into this violent sect back in December 2023, and we are republishing that below. This sect was already well established at that time. Its members (like biological male swimmer competing in women’s sports known as “Lia” Thomas) have been at the forefront of the transgender and gender transformation surgery movement so loudly supported by the American Academy of Pediatrics. There is a seamless continuum from this violent far-left movement to mainstream Democrat party politics.
The threat of organized political violence in the United States comes not from the two-dimensional cutout “Far Right Fascists” and “Far Right MAGA” as so often portrayed in both corporate media and the rantings of Democrat party leaders. That is a convenient projection, whether Freudian or calculated, I cannot say. What is clear is that Democrat party politicians, its media surrogates and apparatchiks have targeted Christians, traditionalists, and Constitutionalists while intentionally downplaying the violence and threat coming from within their own ranks.
They have used the term "The Continued Battle for the Soul of the Nation" to accuse MAGA of being a “Threat to Democracy” and the nation, in a campaign of fear and intimidation to propel them to midterm electoral victory. And now the chickens have come home to roost.
Andrew Austin’s conclusion to his essay is a call to action that rings like a bell. Or perhaps I should say tolls; tolls for a response to the assassination of Charlie Kirk. It is now time to act. Hidden for years behind Signal chatrooms, the enemy within and without has shown its face. Years ago, President Trump saw this threat clearly, called it out, and was ridiculed by Corporate media and his political opponents for doing so.
Americans must denounce left-wing violence clearly and without qualification. This responsibility falls especially on Democrats and progressives, whose rhetoric has too often normalized and justified these ideologies. But how could we expect this when they’re the ones who have normalized and justified these ideologies? One could easily compile clips of progressive leaders stoking unrest (I am watching as I write this). I would like to hope that any readers with these sympathies would confront for themselves the intellectual and moral roots of this problem and turn back from the New Fascism. But I am not hopeful.
Law enforcement, from DHS to the FBI, must take seriously the task of aggressively monitoring and disrupting this reactionary movement. Now is not the time to “dial down the temperature.” This is the moment where the Republic must rise up and crush the enemies of liberty.
When Democrats tell you that Trump and MAGA are the greatest threat to democracy, what they actually mean is that Trump and MAGA, by endeavoring to restore the American Republic to its greatness, is the greatest threat to the technocratic order progressives built and the globalist project they represent to take the world to a planetary corporate neofeudalism. Antifa exists to advance this project.
Antifa and its subculture, Trantifa, operate using a decentralized cell structure hidden behind confidential modern messaging apps like Signal. This is another example of Fourth Generation Warfare tactics and strategy, as developed and operationalized by Al-Qaeda and the Taliban. All of these are terrorist organizations and must be treated as such.
Here is a Perplexity AI summary of how terrorist cells are organized
Essence of a terrorist cell structure:
• Compartmentalization → Each cell only knows what it needs to know. Members often don’t know other cells, or even the full identity of leadership.
• Security through isolation → If one cell is discovered, interrogated, or infiltrated, it can’t compromise the entire network because it lacks the bigger picture.
• Operational flexibility → Cells can work independently on logistics, recruitment, or attacks, so the organization can continue functioning even under pressure.
Think of it like a honeycomb: many small chambers, all contributing to the structure, but separated so that damage in one chamber doesn’t collapse the whole.
I argue that these organizations (Antifa and Trantifa) appear to have used DEI policies to infiltrate both the US Federal Government and Corporate Media during the Obama/Biden administrations. The time to act is now.
Modern terrorism is Fourth Generation Warfare. Antifa and Trantifa are modern left-wing terrorist organizations.
Terrorist organizations often “operationalize” by taking broad ideological goals and translating them into concrete, tactical steps. A key feature of this process is the cell structure, which allows them to operate flexibly while limiting exposure if part of the network is compromised. Here’s how this typically works, again as summarized by Perplexity AI:
1. Strategic Leadership
• At the top, many groups have a central leadership (sometimes a “Shura council” or similar body).
• This leadership sets ideological direction, target priorities, propaganda strategy, and oversees financing.
• Leaders often avoid direct involvement in operations to reduce risk.
2. Decentralization Through Cells
• Cells are small, semi-independent units (often 3–12 members).
Each cell might focus on:
◦ Recruitment
◦ Logistics (weapons, safe houses, transport)
◦ Financing (fundraising, extortion, smuggling)
◦ Operations (planning and carrying out attacks)
• Members of one cell usually know only their own team, not the full organization—this limits infiltration damage.
• Communication between cells often goes through intermediaries or encrypted methods to avoid detection.
3. Operational Planning
• Target selection: Chosen based on symbolism, impact, or vulnerability.
• Surveillance: Cells conduct reconnaissance to study patterns, defenses, and potential escape routes.
• Procurement: Other cells handle weapons, explosives, false documents, or funding.
• Execution: A dedicated operational cell carries out the attack, sometimes with logistical support nearby.
4. Support Networks
• Beyond the “armed” or “operational” wings, groups also maintain:
◦ Propaganda/media arms to recruit and radicalize online or offline.
◦ Social service arms (in some cases) to build community legitimacy.
◦ Front organizations (charities, businesses) for fundraising and laundering money.
5. Global vs. Local Cells
• Some groups (like al-Qaeda) operate as franchises, where local cells pledge allegiance but act independently.
• Others (like some nationalist groups) keep cells tightly controlled by central command.
Tyler Robinson is not a crazy lone wolf, but rather is one representative of a violent leftist movement, “tied to the technocratic order progressives have built, and the globalist project they represent, to take the world to a planetary corporate neofeudalism” that has been hiding in plain sight, under cover of Democrat party Diversity, Equity and Inclusion policies and promoted/weaponized cultural “tolerance” logic.
Wake up and smell the coffee. For Charlie’s sake, if for no other. We have met the enemy. And like an invited vampire, this evil is now within our house. What are we, what are you going to do about it?
We published this essay (linked) on December 13, 2023, and now are republishing it below.
What the Heck is Trantifa?
In the USA, where traditional catholics are considered violent domestic terrorists by the FBI, Antifa and its subsidiary Trantifa, are not. In fact, FBI director Christopher Wrey has stated that he barely recognizes Antifa as a ideology, let alone an organization.
In the USA, where traditional catholics are considered violent domestic terrorists by the FBI, Antifa and its subsidiary Trantifa are not. In fact, FBI director Christopher Wrey has stated that he barely recognizes Antifa as a ideology, let alone an organization.
So, in honor of Riley Gaines and all the other women who have suffered at the hands of Trantifa “activists,” below are a number of news stories that didn’t really make the mainstream news.
But first, lets start with some basic definitions:
Antifa (/ænˈtiːfə, ˈænti(ˌ)fə/) is a left-wing anti-fascist and anti-racist political movement in the United States. It consists of a highly decentralized array of autonomous groups that use nonviolent direct action, incivility, and violence to achieve their aims.
Antifa beliefs include different varieties of anarchism, communism, and socialism and at its core, is anti-capitalist.
Trantifa combines Antifa ideologies with intimidation, harassment, and violence to advance a radical gender agenda. Trantifa members believe that there is no such thing as biological women and men. That gender is fluid.
“Lia” Thomas, is the biological male swimmer competing in women’s sports, and is a member of "Trantifa." Above, he is wearing an “all-black outfit complete with a leather BDSM harness” and wearing a shirt with the slogan, "Antifa Super Soldier."
The truth is that Antifa and its subsidiary, Trantifa are more than just an ideology or a movement, and they must be taken seriously by the government as groups with proven violent tendencies.
A recent event in Portland Oregon shows just how dangerous Trantifa is. The Rose City Antifa organization appears to be directly responsible for the violent attack described below, and Rose City Antifa has even put their planning documents up on their website.
A mob of male transgender-antifa activists attacked a group of women who were standing with a sign as part of a women’s rights activity in Portland on Sunday.
“Four of us at the ER right now. We are in good spirits and remain undefeated. A mob of ‘antifa’ men attacked us, pepper sprayed us in the eyes, punched us, kicked us, and stole our phones. We were attempting to have an event about male violence,” wrote feminist and writer Lierre Kieth. She said that the men stalked the women to their AirBnBs, vandalized their cars as the women prepared to speak at a Women’s Declaration USA’s event in Portland. The trans men also vandalized the library where the feminist training event was taking place, forcing the library to close to the public.
Several reports are describing the attackers as appearing to be transgenders who were wearing masks. The group of women protesters, who were bloodied, bruised, and blinded with pepper spray, describe them as “trantifa.” The women said their phones were targeted, so most of the video is blurry, coming from one body-worn camera that doesn’t show the activists, but that did pick up recordings of the attack.
To find links of videos and audio of this attack, go to Breibart News.
The link for the original news story and the statement from the Women’s Declaration International USA
“Women’s Declaration International USA (WDI USA) strongly condemns the violent attacks on us that took place near the Hollywood branch of the Multnomah County Library on Sunday November 19. In the face of this violent woman-hating terrorism, we are proud to stand with women and girls as a sex class spanning all ages, races, backgrounds, sexual orientations, and circumstances,” the organization wrote on its website. It also criticized Portland police for their inaction.
“Women’s Declaration We also condemn the Portland Police Bureau, which flatly ignored several calls made to 911 while women were being punched, kicked, and pepper-sprayed. Portland police knew of the threat in advance. The library had been vandalized. Our tires were slashed. There had already been security breaches at the library that morning. The cops had driven by and seen the crowd and chose not to disperse it. This was a case of the Portland police knowingly and deliberately abandoning us to a mob,”
Another recent news story reveals that William Whitworth (19) planned to shoot up three schools and also had a communist manifesto in his possession. A clear sign of Trantifa involvement.
Another violent attack on women by Trantifa happened in San Francisco in September.
A women’s event in San Francisco was attacked by Antifa on Saturday, resulting in a Hilton hotel manager being assaulted and others being injured.
According to Reduxx, around 100 members of the Women’s Declaration International US chapter attended the Saturday conference, held at the Chinatown Hilton conference center.
At the event, women spoke on issues such as the right to free speech in academia as a female, and issues concerning black women, lesbians, and detransitioned women.
33-year-old Casey Goonan was reportedly arrested and charged with felony vandalism and resisting arrest resulting in injuries to an officer, with two members of the SFPD being injured during his alleged attempt to escape arrest.
Goonan, who has a PhD in African Studies from Northwestern, was arrested at around 2:45 pm on Saturday.
As Brad of Fives Times August explains:
Other Trantifa Headline News:
Florida Trantifa activist allegedly murdered man, set his home on fire. His trads “Comrades” are trying to free him.
Julio Rosas, an author who recently testified to House lawmakers about leftist extremism, cites a series of trans extremist incidents, including trans shooter Audrey Hale's bloody rampage in a Christian elementary school in Nashville.
'Trans activists gravitate towards these very far-left groups, because they share their anarcho-communist type ideology,' Rosas told DailyMail.com.
'They view the US as systemically racist, that it's subjugated queer people, and that states passing laws against child mutilations is part of a trans genocide. And they're fighting back.'
He described a radicalized group of trans activists concentrated on the East and West coasts who coordinate via messaging apps to stage rallies, confront rivals and push their ideas into the mainstream.
So is Antifa and its counterpart, Trantifa only an ideology, as President Biden has stated? Or is it something more organized?
A clandestine cell system is a method for organizing a group of people, such as resistance fighters, sleeper agents, mobsters, or terrorists, to make it harder for the police or military to catch them. In a cell structure, each of the small groups of people in the cell know the identities of the people only in their own cell. Thus any cell member who is apprehended and interrogated (or who is a mole) will not likely know the identities of the higher-ranking individuals in the organization. -Wiki
Antifa/Trantifa have the hallmarks of being a clandestine cell system. In effect, a secret society with sleeper cells that can be activated.
However, the Antifa Wiki page claims that conspiracy theories about Antifa tend to incorrectly portray antifa as a single organization. Note how Wiki does not address the elephant in the room. Is this an ideology or a “loose” movement or something more? The evidence clearly suggests something more”. Antifa is organized and there may be many organizations but they are connected - as clandestine cell systems.
Evidence that this is a unified organization does exist. For instance, Trantifa International has its own facebook page, even if inactive. The facebook page “about section” even claims: “This page exists as the transgender arm of Antifa.” The Trantifa International facebook page lists 1,700 followers.
Influence Watch writes about the difficulties of defining Antifa and assessing the size of its membership:
Antifa’s lack of centralized structure make it difficult to calculate the movement’s size and membership. While interest has spiked since the 2016 presidential election, it remains virtually impossible to quantify how many people are active members or supporters of Antifa. The chapters of Antifa are loosely connected and highly secretive, and organize mostly on message boards such as Reddit and over social networks like Twitter and Facebook. Liberal commentator Peter Beinart reported, “According to NYC Antifa, the group’s Twitter following nearly quadrupled in the first three weeks of January alone. (By summer, it exceeded 15,000.)” The BBC reported that “It’s Going Down,” an Antifa-aligned website, “which received around 300 hits daily in 2015, now garners between 10-20,000 hits a day.”
Similarly, Antifa’s decentralized character makes it difficult to pin down what exactly it is they oppose. Moreover, this lack of national organization, combined with the group’s secrecy and cloak of anonymity, make the group effectively “impossible to track.”
Are people affiliated with Antifa and Trantifa sleeper cell members, ready to be activated at a moments notice from posts on Signal, Reddit or TikTok ? Who knows?
That Influence Watch article, cites an Antifa guide that advocates for the use of sleeper cells.
So, Antifa and even Trantifa may sound like a hipster song or some sort of sick joke but in fact, they are neither. This is a real organization of (loosely?) affiliated chapters. They keep the identities of their members secret. They keep their organizational structure secret. We do know that they use a cell model - to hide their activies.
Trantifa is a subsidiary of Antifa. They are a real threat and must be taken seriously by the US government.
It has always seemed to me to be the absolute peak of irony that Antifa calls itself antifascist. And most of its low-information members and adherents blindly accept that proposition.
Thank you, Dr. Malone, for this thorough exposé. Knowledge is power. Truth is infinitely powerful.
I heard Stephen Miller speaking yesterday on using the law (He mentioned RICO.) and all available means to go after the organizations like those who groomed and spooled up the Charlie Kirk' murderer. It's high time we did. I've seen this threat coming on for quite a while. I don't mean to scare anyone, but do practice good situational awareness about you when out and about. I fear things may get worse before they get better.