What a well written and interesting look at the history of more than just the Nutcracker. I need a perspective like Jeffrey's after all we've been thru, with more to come. Round and round we go, spinning faster until we get so dizzy that we just fall down. The hero gets up one more time.
Yet Tucker and Dickens reference 2 different periods of history--Dickens the start of the Industrial Revolution, whereas Tucker states the "maturation of the Industrial Revolution"-the gay 90's et al as the fruits of copious energy were coming to all. Energy, energy, Greta be damned, the well being of the common people is always dependent on surplus energy, which present political systems worldwide seem intent on destroying.
I was going to post the same thing about the period. Dickens died in 1870 and even during his lifetime there was improvement all around. The Nutcracker was written 22 years later and, but for the NYC bankers funding the likes of Lennon, the revolution in Russia would not have happened nor the Great War funded by world bankers.
Reading comments here, sounds like there is disagreement as to whether the majority of people flourished because of the I.R or languished in despair and were better off in an agrarian economy.
You beat me to it! That was precisely my first thought - and I was raised on Charles Dickens and George Orwell at school and home, whilst still loving our special treat of a Xmas trip to Covent Garden and Sadlers Wells for the ballet or Opera.
You noticed I rearrange lines from Dickens in my comment. There has never been a year in the life of any society from the beginning of time where classes were not readily identifiable. They are the most prominent feature of any society because it is a natural phenomenon created naturally by individual’s natures within a collective system. We now live in today’s version of communism.
As long as we continue to believe that the class structure is a "natural phenomenon," we will continue to fall into that mass formation psychosis.
There's nothing natural about the class structure of society. It is enforced on us. Read The Theory of the Leisure Class by Thorstein Veblen for the classic analysis of how our class structure started.
We certainly can disagree as to what causes class structure or that it even exists. During the time of (biblical) Abram/Abraham class structure existed. In every Empire throughout history a class structure has existed. Thinking this is naturally so because of the patterns of individual traits and use of free will (physical energy, mental acuity, timidness, boldness, aggressive level) does not lead to mass formation psychosis. The varying levels and numbers of classes in a structure of course varied over time periods and under different influences, but still based in part of the nature of individuals.
Dude, we can do without the condescension. Marx' critique of capitalism was valid; the rich do tend to get richer. Unbridled capitalism leads to unbridled greed. But capitalism in the context of Christianity is another matter. Individual effort fueled by restraint based on faith and obedience changes the dynamic to one of generosity, magnanimity and philanthropy. Countless hospitals have been built in the U.S. by various religious sects. "Do unto others as you would have others do unto you."
Socialism was and remains the only true antidote to ruthless exploitation by a few billionaires: I fait to see why this simple fact is not explained in every village school.
Village schools only exist because of socialism!
Marx did not believe that Russia was ready for socialism - he believed, quite correctly, that to attain socialism you needed a quite sophisticated, modern society, like Western Europe, not a bunch of half-wit serfs and peasants like Joe Stalin.
I think you might be referring to Yule: a Pagan festival of excess. Jesus has nothing to do with the fact that we celebrate the shortest day of the year by eating, drinking, and getting merry - actually if he even existed, he was born at some other random date and would not have approved of it.
Human beings have been celebrating Yule for the last 20,000 years, and we are damned if we will let the God-botherers culturally appropriate our special day.
And now we get to the nub of the matter. We seem to have a language snafu. I say I'm a Christian, but you say I'm a God-botherer. Before you know it, it will be Good Friday. Talk about a bother. That was a real bother. But if it’s all just made up, who cares?
Beautiful article. We have the Nutcracker Ballet performed in our community every year. It is a beautiful performance and all the girls performing know they are performing a timeless piece of art.
When I was a little The Nutcracker would come on the television every Christmas. It was in black and white. I loved to watch the dancers. After we watched the Nutcracker on TV my cousin and I would put the music on the record player get up on the piano bench and leap off twirling and whirling around the room. I love the music from the Nutcracker. Christmas can not come until we have seen or heard music from the Nutcracker.
Music can transport you to another time, Can bring peace to your soul, and it can make you feel all kinds of emotion .
A Christmas gift; thank you! In addition to the harm of the thought of Marx and the actions of Lenin, the impact of Nietzsche was only beginning to be felt and has now come to full flower. His impact on higher education today is palpable, paradoxically akin to a religion, albeit in disguise.
Marx was a brilliant political philosopher, and to describe his work as causing 'harm' is ridiculous. Marx is the reason why we have grown and evolved to care for the sick and disabled, to educate our children, and to feed the poor.
I find the entire narrative on the New Testament to lack any credibility, but I would endorse turning water into wine: that was a cool trick. Shame it didn't actually happen, and neither was Mary a virgin - this kind of nonsense just does not work in an educated society: we all know the New Testament consists mainly of fiction.
Do you not realize that your mind is bound by time and space? Theoretical physics posits the existence of as many as nine realms of reality, perhaps you’ve heard? Kind of gauche to pass judgment on a Being that not only transcends time, space and all other realms, but actually communicated in writing with his three-dimensional creatures and even took on their form. And, it doesn’t hurt His feelings that you have the temerity to question His existence. Not. One. Bit.
The Truth of Scripture is not open to anyone who approaches it with arrogance and disdain. Without humility, your search will be in vain. We spoke earlier about Truth. Jesus said, “I am the way, the truth and the life.” I challenge you to lay aside your preconceptions and take the time to read the book of Matthew in one sitting, with your mind being open to the prospect of just maybe…
I have watched the Nutcracker at various venues in the US and once in Toronto, but had never considered it in this time context, but it makes a great deal of sense and it will never be quite the same to me! At the same time having been a fly on the wall for political events various times I fear these periods of political peace, prosperity, and stability are fleeting because of human failings.
Thank you for sharing this article with us. My memories of the Nutcracker seem to be limited to the rousing, was it - March of the Tin soldiers. On ward to Christmas.
OFF TOPIC: New ET article
Good news of sorts - The Gallop poll
Physians approval rating ranked 69 %, second to nurses at 85%.
Bad News - Public confidence has not waned since 2022 in television and newspaper news.
Unfinished business ....
Wishin' all warm, happy, loving preparations for a wonderful Christmas, holiday.
This was a wonderful uplifting read. I saw the Nutcracker in Detroit in the 90's at their newly renovated and restored symphony hall. I have been collecting Nutcracker's since then. My house is well adorned by many a soldier. I loved the description that they were not killers, they were dignified soldiers.
My spouse will hopefully like it too, and not grouse every year when I drag them out into the open.
So well done and simply full of hope. There is a reason for the three major virtues to become ensconced in our lives: faith , hope and charity are all we need. God is Good.
One of our granddaughters will be on stage this weekend as a 9 year old ballerina in the Nutcracker in Temecula Ca. Daughters and granddaughters have had me a regular attendee of the Nutcracker over the years. Now a wiser 77 year old who’s seen war and tragedy, personal and global, this article reminds me to appreciate the brief moments of time when I can enjoy life, unencumbered by reality. Thank you.
Outstanding article. Thank you for publishing it. I would never have known the depth of meaning in the nutcracker. I wish we could return to such a wonder time and I do believe we must try to move our world in that direction. Those that follow us are dependent on our effort in this regard. I am profoundly aware of the sin problem in this world. It seems we cannot stay in the middle of the road very long at any given time. There is always greed, lust for power and things. The reason, in my world, the Christmas season is so special. Human kind really does need a savior. It is the only real answer to a world that keeps repeating the same dysfunctional behavior over and over d over. May all of you have a beautiful Christmas regardless of your Faith orientation.
Tony, Something about your statement about 'Humankind really does need a Savior.' Got me thinking about how we are never alone, yet we need to save ourselves. How else can we grow? And yet I believe we are watched and guided like the children we are...
What a well written and interesting look at the history of more than just the Nutcracker. I need a perspective like Jeffrey's after all we've been thru, with more to come. Round and round we go, spinning faster until we get so dizzy that we just fall down. The hero gets up one more time.
"There was no limit to prosperity, no limit to peace, no end to the magic that could come to the world."
How is it that the best of times is always followed by the worst of times? The financial founding families’ greed and lust for power.
Nice glimpse by Tucker into a past era. His articles are always well written.
Shelley, an answer to your question,
might be summed up by the following quote:
"Hard times create strong men,
Strong 💪 men create good times,
Good times create weak men and Weak men create hard times!"
By G. Michael Hopf in his novel, "Those Who Remain."
A good explanation of the circle of life.
Anna, do you know whether James is okay, with the weather and all...
D D, I haven't heard.
I have missed his engagement in the conversation.
I pray 🙏 that he is doing well!!!!
Maybe he's busy being Santa 🎅 Claus!!!
You get a bit of a different view of that period reading Dickens one the Russian peasants would likely recognize.
Yet Tucker and Dickens reference 2 different periods of history--Dickens the start of the Industrial Revolution, whereas Tucker states the "maturation of the Industrial Revolution"-the gay 90's et al as the fruits of copious energy were coming to all. Energy, energy, Greta be damned, the well being of the common people is always dependent on surplus energy, which present political systems worldwide seem intent on destroying.
Thanks Tucker for an insightful piece.
I was going to post the same thing about the period. Dickens died in 1870 and even during his lifetime there was improvement all around. The Nutcracker was written 22 years later and, but for the NYC bankers funding the likes of Lennon, the revolution in Russia would not have happened nor the Great War funded by world bankers.
Lol...I expect you meant Lenin (Vladimir) and not Lennon (John)...something to be said about both, though...
The Industrial Revolution began in 1760 according to Toynbee so had been around a while before Dickens began writing
Reading comments here, sounds like there is disagreement as to whether the majority of people flourished because of the I.R or languished in despair and were better off in an agrarian economy.
You beat me to it! That was precisely my first thought - and I was raised on Charles Dickens and George Orwell at school and home, whilst still loving our special treat of a Xmas trip to Covent Garden and Sadlers Wells for the ballet or Opera.
You noticed I rearrange lines from Dickens in my comment. There has never been a year in the life of any society from the beginning of time where classes were not readily identifiable. They are the most prominent feature of any society because it is a natural phenomenon created naturally by individual’s natures within a collective system. We now live in today’s version of communism.
As long as we continue to believe that the class structure is a "natural phenomenon," we will continue to fall into that mass formation psychosis.
There's nothing natural about the class structure of society. It is enforced on us. Read The Theory of the Leisure Class by Thorstein Veblen for the classic analysis of how our class structure started.
We certainly can disagree as to what causes class structure or that it even exists. During the time of (biblical) Abram/Abraham class structure existed. In every Empire throughout history a class structure has existed. Thinking this is naturally so because of the patterns of individual traits and use of free will (physical energy, mental acuity, timidness, boldness, aggressive level) does not lead to mass formation psychosis. The varying levels and numbers of classes in a structure of course varied over time periods and under different influences, but still based in part of the nature of individuals.
Yep.
Classes? oh dear, lets go back to the playground: read Das Kapital, by Karl Marx.
Dude, we can do without the condescension. Marx' critique of capitalism was valid; the rich do tend to get richer. Unbridled capitalism leads to unbridled greed. But capitalism in the context of Christianity is another matter. Individual effort fueled by restraint based on faith and obedience changes the dynamic to one of generosity, magnanimity and philanthropy. Countless hospitals have been built in the U.S. by various religious sects. "Do unto others as you would have others do unto you."
Thank you 😊 SO MUCH for sharing!
Truthfully stated at the end: It is up to us to mend this beautiful toy that we call our freedom!
I do not think you are free. How would you know, exactly?
Oh gee, maybe true reality is just a figment of your imagination. How do we know anything?
I know because I believe His Word!
Galatians 5:1 Standfast therefore in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free, and be not entangled AGAIN with the yoke of bondage!
'Tis the season to be Merry'... Deck the Halls with boughs of Holly'
Said no True Christian, ever!
Oh W-O-W!
I must have missed your appointment of being the official "FACT CHECKER" of True Christian ✝️ 🤔 speech 💬!
Thank 😊 you for the update!
The Russian ethos produced great music composers and novel writers - timeless.
Russian (communist) politics mucked it all up.
Oh dear oh dear.
Socialism was and remains the only true antidote to ruthless exploitation by a few billionaires: I fait to see why this simple fact is not explained in every village school.
Village schools only exist because of socialism!
Marx did not believe that Russia was ready for socialism - he believed, quite correctly, that to attain socialism you needed a quite sophisticated, modern society, like Western Europe, not a bunch of half-wit serfs and peasants like Joe Stalin.
Merry Christmas!
I think you might be referring to Yule: a Pagan festival of excess. Jesus has nothing to do with the fact that we celebrate the shortest day of the year by eating, drinking, and getting merry - actually if he even existed, he was born at some other random date and would not have approved of it.
Human beings have been celebrating Yule for the last 20,000 years, and we are damned if we will let the God-botherers culturally appropriate our special day.
Just trying to be polite to an illiterate.
And now we get to the nub of the matter. We seem to have a language snafu. I say I'm a Christian, but you say I'm a God-botherer. Before you know it, it will be Good Friday. Talk about a bother. That was a real bother. But if it’s all just made up, who cares?
Beautiful article. We have the Nutcracker Ballet performed in our community every year. It is a beautiful performance and all the girls performing know they are performing a timeless piece of art.
When I was a little The Nutcracker would come on the television every Christmas. It was in black and white. I loved to watch the dancers. After we watched the Nutcracker on TV my cousin and I would put the music on the record player get up on the piano bench and leap off twirling and whirling around the room. I love the music from the Nutcracker. Christmas can not come until we have seen or heard music from the Nutcracker.
Music can transport you to another time, Can bring peace to your soul, and it can make you feel all kinds of emotion .
A Christmas gift; thank you! In addition to the harm of the thought of Marx and the actions of Lenin, the impact of Nietzsche was only beginning to be felt and has now come to full flower. His impact on higher education today is palpable, paradoxically akin to a religion, albeit in disguise.
Marx was a brilliant political philosopher, and to describe his work as causing 'harm' is ridiculous. Marx is the reason why we have grown and evolved to care for the sick and disabled, to educate our children, and to feed the poor.
Bullshit
No, that would be Jesus Christ.
I find the entire narrative on the New Testament to lack any credibility, but I would endorse turning water into wine: that was a cool trick. Shame it didn't actually happen, and neither was Mary a virgin - this kind of nonsense just does not work in an educated society: we all know the New Testament consists mainly of fiction.
Do you not realize that your mind is bound by time and space? Theoretical physics posits the existence of as many as nine realms of reality, perhaps you’ve heard? Kind of gauche to pass judgment on a Being that not only transcends time, space and all other realms, but actually communicated in writing with his three-dimensional creatures and even took on their form. And, it doesn’t hurt His feelings that you have the temerity to question His existence. Not. One. Bit.
The Truth of Scripture is not open to anyone who approaches it with arrogance and disdain. Without humility, your search will be in vain. We spoke earlier about Truth. Jesus said, “I am the way, the truth and the life.” I challenge you to lay aside your preconceptions and take the time to read the book of Matthew in one sitting, with your mind being open to the prospect of just maybe…
Beautiful! Thank you 🙏🏻
I have watched the Nutcracker at various venues in the US and once in Toronto, but had never considered it in this time context, but it makes a great deal of sense and it will never be quite the same to me! At the same time having been a fly on the wall for political events various times I fear these periods of political peace, prosperity, and stability are fleeting because of human failings.
Thank you for sharing this article with us. My memories of the Nutcracker seem to be limited to the rousing, was it - March of the Tin soldiers. On ward to Christmas.
OFF TOPIC: New ET article
Good news of sorts - The Gallop poll
Physians approval rating ranked 69 %, second to nurses at 85%.
Bad News - Public confidence has not waned since 2022 in television and newspaper news.
Unfinished business ....
Wishin' all warm, happy, loving preparations for a wonderful Christmas, holiday.
Very Bestest ♡♡♡
This was a wonderful uplifting read. I saw the Nutcracker in Detroit in the 90's at their newly renovated and restored symphony hall. I have been collecting Nutcracker's since then. My house is well adorned by many a soldier. I loved the description that they were not killers, they were dignified soldiers.
My spouse will hopefully like it too, and not grouse every year when I drag them out into the open.
A need-to-read essay for anyone wanting 1) to know
the significance of the Nutcracker Suite and 2) is
concerned about the future of Humanity.
Robert, You spelled Jeffrey's name wrong (as Jeffry) in the lede. Knowing Jeffrey, he will not be happy about it...lol.
Tchaikovsky didn't actually write the story. He composed the music. The libretto was written by someone else.
So well done and simply full of hope. There is a reason for the three major virtues to become ensconced in our lives: faith , hope and charity are all we need. God is Good.
One of our granddaughters will be on stage this weekend as a 9 year old ballerina in the Nutcracker in Temecula Ca. Daughters and granddaughters have had me a regular attendee of the Nutcracker over the years. Now a wiser 77 year old who’s seen war and tragedy, personal and global, this article reminds me to appreciate the brief moments of time when I can enjoy life, unencumbered by reality. Thank you.
Absolutely 💯!
Sometimes, we all need to escape!
Outstanding article. Thank you for publishing it. I would never have known the depth of meaning in the nutcracker. I wish we could return to such a wonder time and I do believe we must try to move our world in that direction. Those that follow us are dependent on our effort in this regard. I am profoundly aware of the sin problem in this world. It seems we cannot stay in the middle of the road very long at any given time. There is always greed, lust for power and things. The reason, in my world, the Christmas season is so special. Human kind really does need a savior. It is the only real answer to a world that keeps repeating the same dysfunctional behavior over and over d over. May all of you have a beautiful Christmas regardless of your Faith orientation.
Tony, Something about your statement about 'Humankind really does need a Savior.' Got me thinking about how we are never alone, yet we need to save ourselves. How else can we grow? And yet I believe we are watched and guided like the children we are...