Covid was a dry run for the tyranny we will certainly face if the communist left takes power in this midterm election and the 2028 presidential election.
The problem we all should fear is if the left gets back into power you can kiss the 1st amendment goodbye. As we witnessed with Covid and the lefts open borders on their 1st go round and the left controlling the 3 branches of government, they silenced the people with censorship. They opened the borders and took peoples voting power away from them. They closed churches and small businesses another source of the people’s power. They jailed political opponents. They even tried to execute their opponents leading candidate. If they regain the 3 branches of government again all hell is sure to break loose. This time there will be a whole new ruthless ruling Democrat regime. Vaccine mandates will be common place. I could see 50 million illegals coming across our borders, spread across the country, completely eliminating people’s voting power. The Supreme Court will be packed. The 1st and 2nd amendment will be eliminated for starters. And things will go down hill from there. Violence and the jailing of people on the right will be common place. So for all the people that think 4.50 a gallon will keep them from the poles, wait and see it get to 10 dollars a gallon if you’re lucky. Voting in these midterms is critical and I would say even more critical than the 2024 election.
Maybe gas prices won't even be an issue if the left wins back power. EV's will become mandatory, so us folks with internal combustion dinosaurs will have to sit in our yards and watch our relics rust, while waiting for our SNAP benefits to arrive. Oh, wait! They won't be OUR yards anymore! They will belong to The People. And we'll have no need for SNAP benefits, as there won't be any grocery stores. Doesn't matter. We won't be able to drive there anyway. Perhaps the regime will use drones to drop ration boxes to the starving masses, if they feel benevolent. Just sayin'.
As usual, a very informative and well-balanced presentation. Thank-you!!
As a GP who was never educated in, nor proficient at, analyzing studies in medical research, and so was (and continues to be) totally dependent on the authorities, the revelation of the significant manipulation of the data and statistical analysis that you and many other well-credentialed scientists provided to those of us who are vulnerable has left me wondering where else these things are happening in our profession.
It reminds me of the time right after Enron had totally fooled those who should have known better and Money Magazine came out with an article purportedly to teach us how to critically analyze companies' financial statements to protect ourselves from another Enron. I immediately cancelled my subscription.
The loss of trust that I experienced during COVID has made me question almost everything I ever did in my medical practice with respect to prevention. I used to joke with my patients that my job was to find something wrong with them to make them keep coming in for follow-up visits and investigation and that most of medicine today is a statistical construct, but when it comes to the individual, statistics are meaningless.
What happens when you can't trust the authorities to do their job right?
You continue to read the Substack articles by people like you to try to stay informed.
Though shared decision making sounds great, until the financial incentives to vaccinate are removed from pediatricians, it will not mean much, especially if the pediatrician is particularly good at convincing the parent that vaccinating is preferable, in his or her opinion. The average lay person is easily intimidated, in my opinion & will cave in most instances.
Additionally, as far as informed consent is concerned, if the information being provided is coming from a biased source (the pediatrician) how much emphasis is being put on the so-called "benefits" & how de-emphasized are the potential harms? The average person is clueless as to how much the whole system is rigged. I also learned in recent years, how much oncologists make from cancer drugs, which they typically purchase in advance at one price, & then charge the patient much, much more. The difference between what the drugs cost them & what the insurance companies reimburse, is substantial, which is what the oncologist keeps. Hence the reason why you will never hear them talk about the potential of re-purposed drugs for cancer, such as Ivermectin, Fenbendazole, & Mebendazole. A close life-long friend developed a rare form of pancreatic & liver cancer a year after receiving three mRNA covid injections & died last December after receiving the typical & conventional cancer treatment. Between what I've learned since 2020 in regard to covid (both the "vaccines" & the suppressed early out-patient treatment for the infection) & then with my friend's cancer diagnosis, there is much to question with both vaccines (all of them) & cancer treatment.
While that may be true, your doctor may also discharge you from his (or her) practice if you fail to get on-board with his (or her) recommendations (vaccines). Since the majority of doctors are now part of a corporate organization & all sing from the same song sheet, trying to find a new doctor, who has an independent practice, is not easy for the average person, especially those with young children.
How better to encourage a return to private practice than refusing to use corporation medical practices? The more we submit to corporate medicine, the more it will control us. It may be difficult to find a private practitioner but it's worth the effort.
Regarding the last paragraph of this essay sadly what I am hearing is that many physicians are as unaware of the risks of some vaccines as is the patient/parent. What is the answer to that?
that was my experience as well. i had a doctor try to force the hpv 'vaccine' on my son; the doctor had zero understanding of the associated risks and had a "must-do" (brainwashed) mentality. That also contributed to my lack of trust in medical professionals who really had no training or education in what they were advocating.
Love this! We need to be cognizant that the pendulum can swing too far in either direction. We should not allow our passions, experience, hurts, or fears to blind us to the truth, whatever the truth is.
People reading this article benefit from the well presented argument to watch out for cultish thinking within ourselves. We are also reminded that voicing an alternative opinion has historically caused personal and public pain and hardship…yet honest and open debate is the only chance for factual information to emerge.
One part towards the end though struck me:
“The physician brings the evidence, experience, and uncertainties.”
I have found that in some (and increasing) circumstances w physicians, the physician is not the one who holds experience or evidence. Alarmingly so with many younger physicians who seem dangerously myopically trained in their specialties and lack a general medical knowledge that former generations of physicians had.
So, I think there are the nefarious characters in medicine/pharmaceuticals and then the mis/un educated.
That may be the bigger problem. Medical knowledge can disappear in more than one way. Sometimes an older technology is not disproven — it simply stops being taught, produced, or seriously re-examined. A generation later, even physicians may no longer know it ever existed.
"Evidence based" is a two edged sword. Conventional medicine says the evidence must come from *this* direction and the tests conducted in *this* way. That automatically throws out individually based modalities such as homeopathy, because it doesn't operate on the same premises. For a long time, acupuncture was belittled and suddenly there was an about face. I never did see what the "evidence" was, but I did see that doctors who had a year in training set themselves up to be the experts, and promptly sidelined traditional acupuncturists who had spent years learning the art. And then there's chiropractic. Where are the "evidence based trials" that conventional medicine will accept?
No, in some cases the evidence is obtained in different ways, and conventional medicine will always throw it out as faulty.
Loss of family because of shots was one of the hardest things during the entire ordeal, I have had to stand alone at times, but will never back down from my right to decide how to live the life I have been given...Thanks for all the insight.
After much research in a medical school library, I decided to not have any more vaccines.
I spoke to small groups in my area about the information I had on vaccinations.
One day I got a call from the mother of a 14 year old boy who had never been vaccinated. He had started a lawn care business in a new subdivision that had been a horse farm 5 years ago.
We discussed his age, the maturity of his immune system and the possibility of being exposed to tetanus. She decided to have him vaccinated for tetanus only.
Is this true for adults who want updated tetanus shots as well? I'm asking because my husband had to go to MedExpress a couple of years ago when he cut his finger with his chain saw. I treated him homeopathically, which helped hugely, but he needed a few stitches, and they were inquiring about his tetanus shot. He avoided it, but what if he had wanted it? Would he have to get the others as well? (Feel free to tell me "look at the links, lazybones." lol)
I am not sure what extreme I fall into. I will not take any mRNA gene therapy injection especially for flue or covid. It doesn't make sense to me, the viruses mutate too fast. When I stopped taking flu shots 8 years ago I stopped getting the flu. Maybe a coincidence. I also intentionally sought out family members (grandchildren) that had tested positive for covid with symptoms to attempt to get infected. I was unsuccessful.
I would carefully weigh the pros and cons for example tetanus injection and try to avoid getting an injection with a multivalent formulation with other diseases included in the package. One at a time if at all please. I have experienced so much obvious misdirection during the covid times that I am deeply skeptical of most vaccine delivery systems. It would be hard to listen to arguments in favor of vaccines, I would have to bite my tongue to pay attention.
So yes I have been accused of being an anti-vaxxer. A label that is basically a thought stopper.
Here is a simple hill to defend; just develop an accurate monitoring system for vaccine injury and there won’t be the need for all these crazy opinions and beliefs. It’s needs to be thorough, accurate and transparent. That is step one and the one sure foundation from which a sound health policy could be built. How could anyone argue against that.
I used to be very pro-vaccine before COVID. I worked in vaccine research and then later in Public Health. I was assured by all of the "experts" that all approved vaccines were thoroughly tested for safety and efficacy and that there were post-licensing safety studies that would ensure that anything missed during the clinical trials would be identified and, if necessary, the vaccine would be pulled from use. The COVID vaccine debacle opened my eyes to how safety issues with vaccines are easily swept under the rug in order to prevent "vaccine hesitancy" - which is enemy number one for public health. I never considered myself to be an anti-vaxxer, though - until I learned that the definition of "anti-vaxxer" including anyone who expressed any reservations about any vaccine at any time. So, I just acknowledge that I am an anti-vaxxer now. Meanwhile, I left my career in Public Health late last year - I just couldn't do it anymore and I found an opportunity to do something else for my career. That all being said, I disagree with Robert Malone that "shared clinical decision-making" is the answer. At least not while the vaccine debate is in its current state. During COVID, most physicians couldn't separate medical fact from fiction - or at least refused to put their medical license on the line to challenge the authority figures at all levels from their hospital admin all the way up to Dr. Fauci. Things are real mess right now. Nobody knows who to listen to or what to believe.
John Adams famously said that "facts are stubborn things."
I could give a fig if Trump supports a vaccine or Fauci or anyone else I just want the facts. Is it efficacious as proven by trials. What are the side effects, if any.
This is why I trust Doc Malone over all these ideologues. He tells it straight. No bullshit, no group think.
I always enjoy your pieces that offer a balanced point of view to the toxic divisions that bedevil our country, and I like this one as well. (Your series on Israel is outstanding, by the way.) But I think you're a bit hard on the anti-vax camp. The vaxxers OWN the controversy and have worked very hard at gate-keeping any information that would induce "vaccine hesitancy." I remember about 8 or 9 years ago, I cautioned a young friend of ours who had married and was starting a family about the possible connection between children's vaccines and autism. She was skeptical and told me she did a Google search and couldn't find anything about it. At that time, it was quite difficult to find anything online. My friend does have a healthy skepticism all round and did realize that it was a bit disturbing that she couldn't find information that I knew was available, even if not readily.
And this that you said: "...a physician should be willing to discuss what is known and what is not, and to defer to a parent free to make the final choice." I agree completely. But I'd like to know what percentage of pediatricians, in particular, are willing even to discuss this with parents. Do you have any figures on that? My sense is that truly open-minded physicians, pediatricians in particular, are miniscule in number.
One thing I think doesn't get discussed as often as it should is the possible price we pay for being immune to certain things. Kennedy said awhile back that if you don't want to get the measles, the best way to avoid it is to be vaccinated. The anti-vax crowd had a kitten, of course, but he was just stating a fact and not talking about the research that has indicated that the high fever associated with measles may be a factor in protection from cancer later in life. Life--and health--is so complicated in our fallen world, and it seems to me that medical intervention can be vastly overrated.
In any case, thanks again for a good and thought-provoking piece. Love to you both.
Great article. Our biggest threat is people who are so sure on their position that it can't be challenged.
Regarding vaccines and autism: It is very difficult to prove something doesn't cause something. If you find the link you have met your burden of proof. Not finding a link says either there wasn't one, or you didn't succeed in your proof. Many studies and court cases have proven a link but not an absolute cause. The vaccine can be a trigger for certain genetic types as explained in this court case.
There is also a document on autism that I can provide that explains the same link when tested in mice, but never calls the 'solution' that causes the effect. They refuse to name it, even though they found the relationship.
Regarding family and not speaking for a year: My daughter refused to speak to us because she didn't understand why we didn't get vaccinated. She would refuse any conversation about it and denied us access to our two grandchildren. This went on for a year and was finally broken when we offered a family trip to Hawaii. The conditions demanded by our daughter were that we don't discuss the vaccination issue. Still to this day, those words can't be spoken.
Regarding seeking out disease: I remember high fiveing my son when we tested positive for Covid. He was vaccinated and staying with us for the holidays and caught it himself. We caught it from him. The reason I was happy to catch it was that society had become so obsessed with Covid that they would claim to protect you from yourself because "you don't know how bad it can be". To be able to say I already had the disease was a huge advantage in those conversations.
We fully vaccinated our children when they were young. My mom sent me to measles parties to catch the disease naturally. You could say I was pro-vaccine until Covid. I saw what was going on (free donuts for getting a vaccine) and the data behind it (R0 value and over 98% survival rate) and started questioning every vaccine to date. Now I see very little reason to get a vaccine but still acknowledge that it may be right for certain people for certain diseases, though that number is small.
Yes. Which should be enough to warrant an investigation. Beyond that, the link has been discovered and is known. A simple test could reveal who is at risk and who isn't, but they don't want that. Similar to discovering who has a peanut allergy before serving lunch, this could reduce the side effects of their product and improve their reputation. But again, they don't seem to care about health; just profits.
An even more extensive look at how we are set up for confusion and the ways it is done. When organizations like Del's and CHD are finally showing the effects of (inevitable?) decay and extremism, how can the ordinary person detect all of this without a degree in the study of personality traits? We are left most of the time to a combination of intuition and study. Thank you for distilling these traits for our education.
Covid was a dry run for the tyranny we will certainly face if the communist left takes power in this midterm election and the 2028 presidential election.
The problem we all should fear is if the left gets back into power you can kiss the 1st amendment goodbye. As we witnessed with Covid and the lefts open borders on their 1st go round and the left controlling the 3 branches of government, they silenced the people with censorship. They opened the borders and took peoples voting power away from them. They closed churches and small businesses another source of the people’s power. They jailed political opponents. They even tried to execute their opponents leading candidate. If they regain the 3 branches of government again all hell is sure to break loose. This time there will be a whole new ruthless ruling Democrat regime. Vaccine mandates will be common place. I could see 50 million illegals coming across our borders, spread across the country, completely eliminating people’s voting power. The Supreme Court will be packed. The 1st and 2nd amendment will be eliminated for starters. And things will go down hill from there. Violence and the jailing of people on the right will be common place. So for all the people that think 4.50 a gallon will keep them from the poles, wait and see it get to 10 dollars a gallon if you’re lucky. Voting in these midterms is critical and I would say even more critical than the 2024 election.
We have essentially lost a chunk of the 1st as we no longer have a free press. In the hands of progressives for decades now
Maybe gas prices won't even be an issue if the left wins back power. EV's will become mandatory, so us folks with internal combustion dinosaurs will have to sit in our yards and watch our relics rust, while waiting for our SNAP benefits to arrive. Oh, wait! They won't be OUR yards anymore! They will belong to The People. And we'll have no need for SNAP benefits, as there won't be any grocery stores. Doesn't matter. We won't be able to drive there anyway. Perhaps the regime will use drones to drop ration boxes to the starving masses, if they feel benevolent. Just sayin'.
And just like the "gravity" that we cannot see....
Wide spread panic and P-ganda bullshit will ensue the nation rapidly.
It's ok to count your chickens before they hatch now.
Because the end result is you'll have no chickens period.
Zero is the sum of nothing but mayhem and malarkey!
Dr. Malone
As usual, a very informative and well-balanced presentation. Thank-you!!
As a GP who was never educated in, nor proficient at, analyzing studies in medical research, and so was (and continues to be) totally dependent on the authorities, the revelation of the significant manipulation of the data and statistical analysis that you and many other well-credentialed scientists provided to those of us who are vulnerable has left me wondering where else these things are happening in our profession.
It reminds me of the time right after Enron had totally fooled those who should have known better and Money Magazine came out with an article purportedly to teach us how to critically analyze companies' financial statements to protect ourselves from another Enron. I immediately cancelled my subscription.
The loss of trust that I experienced during COVID has made me question almost everything I ever did in my medical practice with respect to prevention. I used to joke with my patients that my job was to find something wrong with them to make them keep coming in for follow-up visits and investigation and that most of medicine today is a statistical construct, but when it comes to the individual, statistics are meaningless.
What happens when you can't trust the authorities to do their job right?
You continue to read the Substack articles by people like you to try to stay informed.
Thanks again.
.
If a study on the efficacy of masks originates in Bangladesh, read it very carefully, lol.
Enlightenment ......the highest scoring report card ever in the Universe!
A+
Though shared decision making sounds great, until the financial incentives to vaccinate are removed from pediatricians, it will not mean much, especially if the pediatrician is particularly good at convincing the parent that vaccinating is preferable, in his or her opinion. The average lay person is easily intimidated, in my opinion & will cave in most instances.
Parents and every patient should review and remember who works for whom.
Additionally, as far as informed consent is concerned, if the information being provided is coming from a biased source (the pediatrician) how much emphasis is being put on the so-called "benefits" & how de-emphasized are the potential harms? The average person is clueless as to how much the whole system is rigged. I also learned in recent years, how much oncologists make from cancer drugs, which they typically purchase in advance at one price, & then charge the patient much, much more. The difference between what the drugs cost them & what the insurance companies reimburse, is substantial, which is what the oncologist keeps. Hence the reason why you will never hear them talk about the potential of re-purposed drugs for cancer, such as Ivermectin, Fenbendazole, & Mebendazole. A close life-long friend developed a rare form of pancreatic & liver cancer a year after receiving three mRNA covid injections & died last December after receiving the typical & conventional cancer treatment. Between what I've learned since 2020 in regard to covid (both the "vaccines" & the suppressed early out-patient treatment for the infection) & then with my friend's cancer diagnosis, there is much to question with both vaccines (all of them) & cancer treatment.
A lot of people have learned (or should have learned - many refuse to) a lot about medicine and doctors' motivations during the last six or so years.
You are your doctor’s employer. You can fire him whenever you want to.
While that may be true, your doctor may also discharge you from his (or her) practice if you fail to get on-board with his (or her) recommendations (vaccines). Since the majority of doctors are now part of a corporate organization & all sing from the same song sheet, trying to find a new doctor, who has an independent practice, is not easy for the average person, especially those with young children.
How better to encourage a return to private practice than refusing to use corporation medical practices? The more we submit to corporate medicine, the more it will control us. It may be difficult to find a private practitioner but it's worth the effort.
Insurance limits the choices for yourself and your children.
There’s an iron clad test for who is lying when both sides can’t be right. The liar is the side that is censoring.
And I should have added the lying side is also the one that refuses to debate.
And starts calling names.
In other words, Democrats.
Regarding the last paragraph of this essay sadly what I am hearing is that many physicians are as unaware of the risks of some vaccines as is the patient/parent. What is the answer to that?
that was my experience as well. i had a doctor try to force the hpv 'vaccine' on my son; the doctor had zero understanding of the associated risks and had a "must-do" (brainwashed) mentality. That also contributed to my lack of trust in medical professionals who really had no training or education in what they were advocating.
“Metrics” 🤬 IMHO, HPV is only secondary to the covid shots for adverse effects on our immune system.
Exactly! Much “awareness” is tied to financial incentives and corporate metrics. Parental awareness is the only option.
Love this! We need to be cognizant that the pendulum can swing too far in either direction. We should not allow our passions, experience, hurts, or fears to blind us to the truth, whatever the truth is.
i'll take the non-chemical injection side of the pendulum over the alternative, thank you.
People reading this article benefit from the well presented argument to watch out for cultish thinking within ourselves. We are also reminded that voicing an alternative opinion has historically caused personal and public pain and hardship…yet honest and open debate is the only chance for factual information to emerge.
One part towards the end though struck me:
“The physician brings the evidence, experience, and uncertainties.”
I have found that in some (and increasing) circumstances w physicians, the physician is not the one who holds experience or evidence. Alarmingly so with many younger physicians who seem dangerously myopically trained in their specialties and lack a general medical knowledge that former generations of physicians had.
So, I think there are the nefarious characters in medicine/pharmaceuticals and then the mis/un educated.
Thanks for a superb article.
That may be the bigger problem. Medical knowledge can disappear in more than one way. Sometimes an older technology is not disproven — it simply stops being taught, produced, or seriously re-examined. A generation later, even physicians may no longer know it ever existed.
And I agree. The medical training received by this new generation of doctors is lacking in evidence-based information.
"Evidence based" is a two edged sword. Conventional medicine says the evidence must come from *this* direction and the tests conducted in *this* way. That automatically throws out individually based modalities such as homeopathy, because it doesn't operate on the same premises. For a long time, acupuncture was belittled and suddenly there was an about face. I never did see what the "evidence" was, but I did see that doctors who had a year in training set themselves up to be the experts, and promptly sidelined traditional acupuncturists who had spent years learning the art. And then there's chiropractic. Where are the "evidence based trials" that conventional medicine will accept?
No, in some cases the evidence is obtained in different ways, and conventional medicine will always throw it out as faulty.
Loss of family because of shots was one of the hardest things during the entire ordeal, I have had to stand alone at times, but will never back down from my right to decide how to live the life I have been given...Thanks for all the insight.
After much research in a medical school library, I decided to not have any more vaccines.
I spoke to small groups in my area about the information I had on vaccinations.
One day I got a call from the mother of a 14 year old boy who had never been vaccinated. He had started a lawn care business in a new subdivision that had been a horse farm 5 years ago.
We discussed his age, the maturity of his immune system and the possibility of being exposed to tetanus. She decided to have him vaccinated for tetanus only.
Truly informed consent.
How long ago did that take place? Because you can no longer get a “tetanus only” shot in the USA.
As far as I know, it is always a DTP combination. I do maintain vaccination against tetanus.
Are you serious? What is included with it?
Pertussis and diphtheria vaccines.
You can learn more about all the Tetanus shots here:
https://www.nvic.org/disease-vaccine/tetanus/vaccine
And also here:
https://physiciansforinformedconsent.org/
Is this true for adults who want updated tetanus shots as well? I'm asking because my husband had to go to MedExpress a couple of years ago when he cut his finger with his chain saw. I treated him homeopathically, which helped hugely, but he needed a few stitches, and they were inquiring about his tetanus shot. He avoided it, but what if he had wanted it? Would he have to get the others as well? (Feel free to tell me "look at the links, lazybones." lol)
thank you for this
I am not sure what extreme I fall into. I will not take any mRNA gene therapy injection especially for flue or covid. It doesn't make sense to me, the viruses mutate too fast. When I stopped taking flu shots 8 years ago I stopped getting the flu. Maybe a coincidence. I also intentionally sought out family members (grandchildren) that had tested positive for covid with symptoms to attempt to get infected. I was unsuccessful.
I would carefully weigh the pros and cons for example tetanus injection and try to avoid getting an injection with a multivalent formulation with other diseases included in the package. One at a time if at all please. I have experienced so much obvious misdirection during the covid times that I am deeply skeptical of most vaccine delivery systems. It would be hard to listen to arguments in favor of vaccines, I would have to bite my tongue to pay attention.
So yes I have been accused of being an anti-vaxxer. A label that is basically a thought stopper.
Here is a simple hill to defend; just develop an accurate monitoring system for vaccine injury and there won’t be the need for all these crazy opinions and beliefs. It’s needs to be thorough, accurate and transparent. That is step one and the one sure foundation from which a sound health policy could be built. How could anyone argue against that.
If there's one thing pharmaceutical companies do not want, it's a sound health policy.
Jeff: "...thorough, accurate and transparent." What a concept!
I used to be very pro-vaccine before COVID. I worked in vaccine research and then later in Public Health. I was assured by all of the "experts" that all approved vaccines were thoroughly tested for safety and efficacy and that there were post-licensing safety studies that would ensure that anything missed during the clinical trials would be identified and, if necessary, the vaccine would be pulled from use. The COVID vaccine debacle opened my eyes to how safety issues with vaccines are easily swept under the rug in order to prevent "vaccine hesitancy" - which is enemy number one for public health. I never considered myself to be an anti-vaxxer, though - until I learned that the definition of "anti-vaxxer" including anyone who expressed any reservations about any vaccine at any time. So, I just acknowledge that I am an anti-vaxxer now. Meanwhile, I left my career in Public Health late last year - I just couldn't do it anymore and I found an opportunity to do something else for my career. That all being said, I disagree with Robert Malone that "shared clinical decision-making" is the answer. At least not while the vaccine debate is in its current state. During COVID, most physicians couldn't separate medical fact from fiction - or at least refused to put their medical license on the line to challenge the authority figures at all levels from their hospital admin all the way up to Dr. Fauci. Things are real mess right now. Nobody knows who to listen to or what to believe.
Mike, Well, "NOBODY knows who to listen to or what to believe." Um...I do.
A pox on both their houses.
John Adams famously said that "facts are stubborn things."
I could give a fig if Trump supports a vaccine or Fauci or anyone else I just want the facts. Is it efficacious as proven by trials. What are the side effects, if any.
This is why I trust Doc Malone over all these ideologues. He tells it straight. No bullshit, no group think.
I always enjoy your pieces that offer a balanced point of view to the toxic divisions that bedevil our country, and I like this one as well. (Your series on Israel is outstanding, by the way.) But I think you're a bit hard on the anti-vax camp. The vaxxers OWN the controversy and have worked very hard at gate-keeping any information that would induce "vaccine hesitancy." I remember about 8 or 9 years ago, I cautioned a young friend of ours who had married and was starting a family about the possible connection between children's vaccines and autism. She was skeptical and told me she did a Google search and couldn't find anything about it. At that time, it was quite difficult to find anything online. My friend does have a healthy skepticism all round and did realize that it was a bit disturbing that she couldn't find information that I knew was available, even if not readily.
And this that you said: "...a physician should be willing to discuss what is known and what is not, and to defer to a parent free to make the final choice." I agree completely. But I'd like to know what percentage of pediatricians, in particular, are willing even to discuss this with parents. Do you have any figures on that? My sense is that truly open-minded physicians, pediatricians in particular, are miniscule in number.
One thing I think doesn't get discussed as often as it should is the possible price we pay for being immune to certain things. Kennedy said awhile back that if you don't want to get the measles, the best way to avoid it is to be vaccinated. The anti-vax crowd had a kitten, of course, but he was just stating a fact and not talking about the research that has indicated that the high fever associated with measles may be a factor in protection from cancer later in life. Life--and health--is so complicated in our fallen world, and it seems to me that medical intervention can be vastly overrated.
In any case, thanks again for a good and thought-provoking piece. Love to you both.
I enjoyed your writing this comment here in addition to the Malones piece!
Aniela, Well stated! You make important points, especially mentioning that connection between measles fever and cancer protection.
Great article. Our biggest threat is people who are so sure on their position that it can't be challenged.
Regarding vaccines and autism: It is very difficult to prove something doesn't cause something. If you find the link you have met your burden of proof. Not finding a link says either there wasn't one, or you didn't succeed in your proof. Many studies and court cases have proven a link but not an absolute cause. The vaccine can be a trigger for certain genetic types as explained in this court case.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/family-to-receive-15m-plus-in-first-ever-vaccine-autism-court-award/
There is also a document on autism that I can provide that explains the same link when tested in mice, but never calls the 'solution' that causes the effect. They refuse to name it, even though they found the relationship.
Regarding family and not speaking for a year: My daughter refused to speak to us because she didn't understand why we didn't get vaccinated. She would refuse any conversation about it and denied us access to our two grandchildren. This went on for a year and was finally broken when we offered a family trip to Hawaii. The conditions demanded by our daughter were that we don't discuss the vaccination issue. Still to this day, those words can't be spoken.
Regarding seeking out disease: I remember high fiveing my son when we tested positive for Covid. He was vaccinated and staying with us for the holidays and caught it himself. We caught it from him. The reason I was happy to catch it was that society had become so obsessed with Covid that they would claim to protect you from yourself because "you don't know how bad it can be". To be able to say I already had the disease was a huge advantage in those conversations.
We fully vaccinated our children when they were young. My mom sent me to measles parties to catch the disease naturally. You could say I was pro-vaccine until Covid. I saw what was going on (free donuts for getting a vaccine) and the data behind it (R0 value and over 98% survival rate) and started questioning every vaccine to date. Now I see very little reason to get a vaccine but still acknowledge that it may be right for certain people for certain diseases, though that number is small.
Too many instances of healthy kids becoming autistic immediately following a jab for any study 'proving"them innocent to bebelieved
Yes. Which should be enough to warrant an investigation. Beyond that, the link has been discovered and is known. A simple test could reveal who is at risk and who isn't, but they don't want that. Similar to discovering who has a peanut allergy before serving lunch, this could reduce the side effects of their product and improve their reputation. But again, they don't seem to care about health; just profits.
Mike, Well stated. And, Absolutism: Blanket Certainty always held by people who do not understand how things on planet Earth work. LOL - Probably...
'You could say I was pro-vaccine until Covid.'
An even more extensive look at how we are set up for confusion and the ways it is done. When organizations like Del's and CHD are finally showing the effects of (inevitable?) decay and extremism, how can the ordinary person detect all of this without a degree in the study of personality traits? We are left most of the time to a combination of intuition and study. Thank you for distilling these traits for our education.