What happened to “Copying is the sincerest form of flattery”? Once a “style” is out in the open market to be appreciated by millions, exclusive ownership disappears…… Get over it!
People need to quit being so small and petty. There are enough real problems in this world that need our attention and not this pathetic drivel.
Thanks so much. I live in Florida where most of the year it is HOT. I wear dashikis most of the time. They are native to Africa and are very lose and cool. Mine are 100% cotton so are breathable. In the last 20 years no one has noticed, until one day in a parking lot I was told by a black man that I was not native to Africa so I should not wear their clothing.
I hope someone pointed out that he was on the wrong continent and needed to remove himself immediately because his ancestors 20 generations back weren’t born here.
Why shouldn’t a “ white” person wearing a kimono simply “ identify” as Japanese? No more ridiculous than a biological person of one sex identifying as another “gender”.
Of course, spot-on observations about this stupid concept. Cultural appropriation is ignorance built on a foundation of profound arrogance. Hence, no surprise that the origin is in the modern university. As pointed out, another manufactured 'offense' to divide races.
I recently heard a Sacha Baron Cohen joke when he was conversing with a liberal egghead that went something like: "Is it OK for a white person to play jazz, as long as he isn't very good."
In my youth, I was a member of the Indian Guides. A precursor to scouting. Each group identified with a specific, native American tribe and copied their clothing and bead work, even learning their group dances where possible. We learned and emulated their concerns for the environment and their conservative use of resources. What public venue should I use to confess my cultural misappropriation guilt?
Indeed, our local YMCA started the Indian Guide program in the mid-50’s. Dads and sons wearing headbands. Meeting weekly. Having an Indian theme was special, forming into tribes, adopting Indian names. The dads probably said “How!” a little too often, but we all had a shared respect of the Native American culture. Why not!!!
The Boy Scouts took the idea further with the Order of the Arrow and the whole concept of merit badges using adults with special skills to test the scouts, just like a young brave would “apprentice” with the wrangler, the arrow head maker, the hunter, the fire starter, etc.
I was obsessed with Indian lore and used to practice walking through the woods without making noise as much as possible, avoiding snapping twigs or rustling leaves, like I read that the smart Indian hunters did. One year, a neighbor loaned me an Indian dress and I wore it for Halloween (with braids in my hair). That was then, this is now.
It occurred to me some ways back that perpetual agitation is the point. It's not meant to make true sense; it's meant to demoralize, and it works. It's the slow, corrosive tactic of those who undermine. See cultural marxism, and the Frankfurt School.
The cultural appropriation B.S. is an invention of manipulators who seek do divide people so that they can conquer and more easily kill them off and take their property.
People are sent to university so that they can be trained as tools. Their poisoned minds become self destructive.
For example, a good number of them have stopped reproducing due to inculcated "climate change" fears.
Similarly minorities infected by the universities seek to be entirely forgotten by limiting who can utilize, and therefore remember their styles, culture and contributions. The most blatant losers are the university "educated", and usually mixed, first USA immigrants.
It is self erasure.
I do not cooperate.
(Don't forget that the majority of people are mixed race. People have been mingling for a very long time.)
I saw a video yesterday on YouTube showing mummified grave finds in China of blonde Caucasian women with braided hair. Hair braiding certainly goes back at least as far as the great Ice age.
Not surprising that hair braiding goes back centuries. It is not exactly rocket science to find it convenient and comfortable to secure long hair in a simple braid.
Spot on! in reference to "shouldn’t American ranchers abandon the saddles, bits, riding techniques, and cattle-handling practices inherited from Spanish and Mexican vaqueros?" I would like to comment that my grandpa, who lived to the ripe old age just short of 102 years old, would drive his Cadillac sedan to herd the cattle around on the rough prairie pastures of Montana. It's no wonder that he bought a new Cadillac every year. I told the family that it should have been named Cattle-ac. Also, regarding people who want ownership of the practice of braiding hair...it's an ancient practice. The Bible references regarding women braiding their hair can be found in 1 Timothy 2:9-10 and 1 Peter 3:3-4, where it advises women to focus on modesty and inner beauty rather than extravagant hairstyles and adornments.
Indigenous North Americans, at least in the more northern areas, learned and adopted textile skills from the european settlers. Such as spinning yarn, weaving, making fulled woolen blankets instead of using buffalo hides for warmth, sewing with beads and embroidery, and the knitting of Cowichan sweaters. Was that cultural appropriation on their part?
My biggest cultural appropriation issues have been in the entertainment industry. Hamilton had many white characters played by black actors. Same with Six. The acting was fine but there weren’t any white actors available to play historically accurate white individuals?
I don’t hear about the Swiss being offended by others making Swiss cheese, they just certify that theirs is authentic. Old hippies don’t seem offended by others wearing tie-dyed t shirts and bell bottoms. This is just silly and stupid whining.
What happened to “Copying is the sincerest form of flattery”? Once a “style” is out in the open market to be appreciated by millions, exclusive ownership disappears…… Get over it!
People need to quit being so small and petty. There are enough real problems in this world that need our attention and not this pathetic drivel.
Bullseye. Take a look at a “Safe Tap Water Map of the World”. Hmmmm.
Looks like some countries could use some cultural appropriation, or at least some (treading delicately) Plumbing Supremacy.
Thanks so much. I live in Florida where most of the year it is HOT. I wear dashikis most of the time. They are native to Africa and are very lose and cool. Mine are 100% cotton so are breathable. In the last 20 years no one has noticed, until one day in a parking lot I was told by a black man that I was not native to Africa so I should not wear their clothing.
I hope someone pointed out that he was on the wrong continent and needed to remove himself immediately because his ancestors 20 generations back weren’t born here.
There are Caucasians who were born in Africa— his thesis is inherently incoherent.
I'm curious, what did you say to him?
Why shouldn’t a “ white” person wearing a kimono simply “ identify” as Japanese? No more ridiculous than a biological person of one sex identifying as another “gender”.
Of course, spot-on observations about this stupid concept. Cultural appropriation is ignorance built on a foundation of profound arrogance. Hence, no surprise that the origin is in the modern university. As pointed out, another manufactured 'offense' to divide races.
I recently heard a Sacha Baron Cohen joke when he was conversing with a liberal egghead that went something like: "Is it OK for a white person to play jazz, as long as he isn't very good."
In my youth, I was a member of the Indian Guides. A precursor to scouting. Each group identified with a specific, native American tribe and copied their clothing and bead work, even learning their group dances where possible. We learned and emulated their concerns for the environment and their conservative use of resources. What public venue should I use to confess my cultural misappropriation guilt?
Well Nicholas, I guess we are of similar age, as I too was in Indian Guides in Akron, Ohio 🤣.
Indeed, our local YMCA started the Indian Guide program in the mid-50’s. Dads and sons wearing headbands. Meeting weekly. Having an Indian theme was special, forming into tribes, adopting Indian names. The dads probably said “How!” a little too often, but we all had a shared respect of the Native American culture. Why not!!!
The Boy Scouts took the idea further with the Order of the Arrow and the whole concept of merit badges using adults with special skills to test the scouts, just like a young brave would “apprentice” with the wrangler, the arrow head maker, the hunter, the fire starter, etc.
I was obsessed with Indian lore and used to practice walking through the woods without making noise as much as possible, avoiding snapping twigs or rustling leaves, like I read that the smart Indian hunters did. One year, a neighbor loaned me an Indian dress and I wore it for Halloween (with braids in my hair). That was then, this is now.
It occurred to me some ways back that perpetual agitation is the point. It's not meant to make true sense; it's meant to demoralize, and it works. It's the slow, corrosive tactic of those who undermine. See cultural marxism, and the Frankfurt School.
Exactly.
The cultural appropriation B.S. is an invention of manipulators who seek do divide people so that they can conquer and more easily kill them off and take their property.
People are sent to university so that they can be trained as tools. Their poisoned minds become self destructive.
For example, a good number of them have stopped reproducing due to inculcated "climate change" fears.
Similarly minorities infected by the universities seek to be entirely forgotten by limiting who can utilize, and therefore remember their styles, culture and contributions. The most blatant losers are the university "educated", and usually mixed, first USA immigrants.
It is self erasure.
I do not cooperate.
(Don't forget that the majority of people are mixed race. People have been mingling for a very long time.)
I saw a video yesterday on YouTube showing mummified grave finds in China of blonde Caucasian women with braided hair. Hair braiding certainly goes back at least as far as the great Ice age.
Not surprising that hair braiding goes back centuries. It is not exactly rocket science to find it convenient and comfortable to secure long hair in a simple braid.
Good analysis! A mental construct to divide and change cultural norms!
Spot on! in reference to "shouldn’t American ranchers abandon the saddles, bits, riding techniques, and cattle-handling practices inherited from Spanish and Mexican vaqueros?" I would like to comment that my grandpa, who lived to the ripe old age just short of 102 years old, would drive his Cadillac sedan to herd the cattle around on the rough prairie pastures of Montana. It's no wonder that he bought a new Cadillac every year. I told the family that it should have been named Cattle-ac. Also, regarding people who want ownership of the practice of braiding hair...it's an ancient practice. The Bible references regarding women braiding their hair can be found in 1 Timothy 2:9-10 and 1 Peter 3:3-4, where it advises women to focus on modesty and inner beauty rather than extravagant hairstyles and adornments.
Indigenous North Americans, at least in the more northern areas, learned and adopted textile skills from the european settlers. Such as spinning yarn, weaving, making fulled woolen blankets instead of using buffalo hides for warmth, sewing with beads and embroidery, and the knitting of Cowichan sweaters. Was that cultural appropriation on their part?
Dear Drs. Malone,
Embarrassing as it is, I learned how to
• Disco boogie from a black guy in ‘79.
• Grew long hair just like Jesus Christ. I’m Italian, he was Jewish, so that counts as appropriation, right?
• And most importantly, an ex-Somali pirate taught me how to make money from non-existent day care centers!
It’s been a wild ride but there’s truly nothing like cultural appropriation.
Your pal,
J.
Thank you for this
Well dang! Guess I should never eat sushi or tacos again. Clearly appropriation.
My biggest cultural appropriation issues have been in the entertainment industry. Hamilton had many white characters played by black actors. Same with Six. The acting was fine but there weren’t any white actors available to play historically accurate white individuals?
I don’t hear about the Swiss being offended by others making Swiss cheese, they just certify that theirs is authentic. Old hippies don’t seem offended by others wearing tie-dyed t shirts and bell bottoms. This is just silly and stupid whining.