181 Comments
User's avatar
ComeQuicklyLord's avatar

Thank you for the Audio and Written transcript. These essays have been thought provoking.

Israel turned over Gaza to its occupants in 2005, which included functioning green houses, that provided Israel and Europe with vegetables, to include watermelon—it was a multi-million dollar business, which Israeli’s were forced to abandon.

As soon as the Israelis left, the green houses, synagogues, and other buildings were systematically destroyed, out of pure hatred for the Jewish people. When they realized they destroyed an an agricultural and rvonomic opportunity they asked Israel to help rebuild them—crickets, for just reasons.

After receiving billions of dollars of International Aide, instead of building a robust economy and infrastructure, they created, IMO, the world’s largest welfare state, and a structure that foments hatred toward the Jewish people, and America.

They could have created a government that openly trades with Israel, but did not, and IMO, still refuses to do so. How can a person, let alone a government, help those who refuse to grow and thrive on their own, but rather, insists on your destruction? Hatred and envy are destructive behaviors.

May God grant Israel and the United States wisdom to maneuver through this political and ideological mine field.

Dr. Robert W. Malone's avatar

Very difficult moral landscape

Micheal Nash, Ph. D.'s avatar

Hard to expect much enterprise from a population whose education extends little beyond learning how to disassemble and reassemble an AK47

Jack Bergeron's avatar

Intelligence and knowledge do not guarantee wisdom. What do the people in Gaza do to feed themselves? Wise people work and find means to free themselves from the entrapment of dependence upon other nations for daily necessities. People who fail to work and produce for themselves deserve neither respect nor continued support.

Jacob99's avatar

You are wrong. The world spent so much money on Gaza. They had very well equipped schools

Micheal Nash, Ph. D.'s avatar

With lots of AK47s to disassembls and reassemble.

Jacob99's avatar

Before the outbreak of the war in October 2023, the education system in Gaza presented a striking paradox: high educational attainment and near-universal literacy existing alongside severe structural constraints, resource shortages, and economic limitations. Education was widely considered a cornerstone of Palestinian society and a primary avenue for socio-economic mobility. Level of Education & AccessNear-Universal Literacy: Gaza maintained one of the lowest illiteracy rates in the world (around 1.8%). Youth literacy (ages 15–24) was nearly 99%. High School Enrollment: Primary and lower-secondary school gross enrollment rates routinely exceeded 95% to 97% for both boys and girls. Gender parity was strong, with female completion rates in secondary education often exceeding male completion rates. Higher Education: Gaza had a vibrant tertiary sector with over 12 universities and higher education institutions (such as the Islamic University of Gaza, Al-Azhar University, and the University College of Applied Sciences) and over 20 colleges. Gross tertiary enrollment was around 40–45%, which was relatively high by regional standards. Focus on the Tawjihi: Passing the Tawjihi (the general secondary education matriculation examination) was a critical national milestone required for university admission.Structure & Provision of EducationSchooling in Gaza was provided by three main actors:UNRWA (UN Relief and Works Agency): Educated around 50–60% of primary and preparatory (middle school) students, serving the vast population of registered Palestinian refugees. UNRWA schools followed the national Palestinian curriculum supplemented by human rights education.Palestinian Authority / Local Administration: Managed the public school system, including almost all secondary schools (high schools) and several universities.Private Sector: Accounted for a smaller percentage of specialized private primary, secondary, and international schools. Quality of Education & Everyday ChallengesWhile enthusiasm for education was high and foundational skills (reading, writing, numeracy) were solid, the actual quality and operational environment of schools faced intense pressure:Double-Shift System: Due to a severe shortage of school buildings, a vast majority of UNRWA and government schools operated on a "double-shift" model (one set of students in the morning, a second set in the afternoon). This reduced daily instructional hours by up to 20–30%.Overcrowding: Class sizes frequently averaged 35 to 45 students per classroom.Blockade and Infrastructure Constraints: The long-standing blockade restricted entry of construction materials, making it difficult to build new schools or upgrade aging facilities. Materials like computers, laboratory supplies, and updated textbooks were frequently delayed or prohibited. Power Shortages & Economic Crisis: Chronic electricity cuts forced students to study by candlelight or battery light at home. Soaring youth unemployment (often exceeding 60–70%) meant that even university graduates faced few domestic job opportunities. Mobility Restrictions: Top-performing students faced immense difficulty securing permits to study abroad or even attend universities in the West Bank. Despite these material deficits, academic dedication remained central to family life, and Gaza produced strong academic results relative to the resources available.

mspring's avatar

Interesting, but all that education didn't change the fundamental paradigms of Islam and it's hatred for the west (not just the Jews, but US, Europe, etc as well) in this context "hatred" is complex. At one level, it is just the world of war (western infidels who must be assimilated) vs the world of peace (all areas under muslim control) on another level, the visceral hatred of anyone not muslim that destroyed Constantinople and fuels Hamas, Hezbolla, atrocities.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 4
Comment deleted
Beyond Spin's avatar

Robert you must be getting really great hasbara money for all this tripe. Regardless, the one book he should have read, but didn't, is Benny Morris's 1948 and After.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/0198279299

This book was also written before Morris became such a Zionist apologist. In this book, Morris goes through Israeli historical archives recorded during 1948 and dispels a lot of the prevailing Zionist myths. The main difference betw. Morris's book and Pappe's book, The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, is that Morris argues that there was no Plan Dalet ("Plan D"). Otherwise, their conclusions were strikingly similar, with Morris acknowledging Israel committed the first sin.

When you're raised in a Jewish community, as I was, you just accept the revised historical narrative and mythology that you were indoctrinated to believe. So, when you actually start exploring the real history, it's quite shocking and disconcerting to realize what Zionist militia, only a few years after the Holocaust, did to another people. The Irgun and Stern Gang were especially immoral.

And contrary to Morris's position, recently discovered records detail how Zionist militias did coordinate their attacks.

Chris Coles FRSA's avatar

May I also suggest that Dr's Malone, and their wider family sit down and watch a four part series broadcast on the UK Channel 4 TV titled: The promise.

6 February 2011

The Promise, a new 4-part drama from acclaimed writer/director Peter Kosminsky, stars Claire Foy (Little Dorrit, Upstairs Downstairs) and Christian Cooke (Cemetery Junction) in the lead roles.

The Promise tells the story of two British characters - Erin (Claire Foy), an 18-year-old Londoner who visits present-day Israel for the first time, and her grandfather, Len (Christian Cooke) - a soldier in the British peace-keeping force in 1940s Palestine.

Erin's best friend Eliza (Perdita Weeks) has joint British/Israeli nationality although she lives in the UK. She travels to Israel to carry out National Service in the army and invites Erin to join her for the summer.

Erin is anticipating a summer of parties and attractive, young Israeli men but just before she departs she finds her sick grandfather's diary. She starts to read it en route to Israel and learns about his life in the army in the then Palestine. She discovers Len witnessed first-hand the atrocities of the Holocaust and the violent events that occurred when the modern state of Israel was established.

Moved by Len's account and the realisation he wasn't much older than her when he wrote it, Erin retraces his steps in modern day Israel. Her journey is exhilarating and turbulent in equal measure. She is forced to confront the drama, complexity and tragedy of life in this troubled land for Jews and Palestinians alike. She also uncovers the disturbing conclusion to her grandfather's service in the Middle East and a deep love and understanding for a man she had naively written off as old and irrelevant.

Peter Kosminsky and his team have extensively researched The Promise for the past seven years. Although the story it tells is fictional it is inspired by the testimony of many British soldiers, Israelis and Palestinians who recalled the Mandate period and life in Israel/Palestine today.

Acclaimed Israeli and Arab actors - including Itay Tiran (Lebanon), Haaz Sleiman (The Visitor), Hiam Abbass (The Visitor) and Ali Suliman (Paradise Now) - feature alongside Foy and Cooke.

The international cast also includes Katharina Schüttler (Truth or Dare), Perdita Weeks (Lost in Austen), Holly Aird (Waking the Dead), Ulrich Noethen (Downfall), Iain McKee (The Visit), Ben Miles (Lark Rise to Candleford) and Lucas Gregorowicz (Soul Kitchen).

The drama serial is commissioned for Channel 4 by Head of Drama Camilla Campbell. It is produced by Hal Vogel and executive produced by David Aukin for Daybreak Pictures, a division of Mentorn Media.

The Promise is a Channel 4 co-production with Canal + and Arte.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1692202/

MarKe's avatar

I wouldn't put any stock in an Israel/Arab drama coming out of the anti Semitic UK. Acclaimed, indeed. Acclaimed for division, denial of free speech and betrayal of its own people. Anti Semitic way before the present crisis. No interest whatsoever. The UK is mostly done.

Thomas A Braun RPh's avatar

This seems to be a unretractable problem that goes back centuries. If I recall properly, there was a period of almost two hundred years in Spain around 900 AD when Jews, Muslims and Christians all lived in piece with each other. Maybe that time period needs to be studied to come up with a solution. The problem I see is the ever escalating military technology is becoming more and more sophisticated and deadly, and can result in a global conflagration where survival is questionable. Israel's nuclear capability is never on the table and that is scary. North Korea is also a wild card. Then we have Pakistan and India having a dislike for each other. No clue where China stands and of course we have the Russian issue. Einstein and Madam Curie should have pursued other avenues of science. New generations of extreme hate just keep being generated and the conflict continues.

Micheal Nash, Ph. D.'s avatar

One entry into the equasion was,the incorporation of the Turks into the Muslin congregation who promptly took over the works and brought them beck to the 7th century comfort zone

ALToronto's avatar

The "Golden Age" in Spain was a period of dhimmitude, where Christians and Jews had to pay a special tax and agree to be treated as second-class citizens. It was the sort of "peace" that you get when you give the school bully your lunch money. This part of history has been sanitized to make Muslim dominance appear magnanimous. It wasn't.

Barbara Charis's avatar

The narrow mindset of the Gazan, who are in a cult, which does not embrace education or morals. It does not recognize the rights of any others to exist. It supports murder, thievery and lying. How do you deal with those who believe killing infidels will guarantee them a place in Paradise?

anna george's avatar

An amazing read! Thank you for what must have been days to put together.

Historical content to which I had no idea nor any way to ever get. We Americans do Not understand either these people or what they are forced to do to simply survive. I’ll never understand the hatred of the Jewish people. Why? They appear to be “regular people”, have a religion that goes back centuries but other countries want them gone which will never happen. They are God’s chosen. Sadly, it just has to be demonic.

Robert Wistedt's avatar

They are NOT god's Chosen = just another Zionist JEW lie like the HOHOHOAX !

YosefChaim's avatar

This is a complete misunderstanding.

Chosen = Eved Hashem... we are the servants to G-d and his children Genesis 2.7

Zionists

16 million Jews on earth with approximately 8 million Zionists with a major majority living in Israel

Conversely 40 - 60 million Christian Zionists in America alone.

When you post your hatred make sure you know what you are talking about otherwise you look like an idiot

Lee Tidwell's avatar

Not all of us Christians bought the zionist bs, hook-line&sinker.

https://zirafa.substack.com/p/the-scofield-bible

Some of us use the unedited version of the bible.

https://www.biblestudytools.com/commentaries/matthew-henry-complete/

YosefChaim's avatar

2 billion followers of Saints & Jesus.

1.5 billion Catholics

500 million "Christians"

40 to 60 million American Christians are Zionists

I never said all... read what I said not what youd like it to say so you can challenge me.

We probably agree on more points than we disagree.

Just for clarification which version of the Bible do you read? Septuagint?

Gail Benton's avatar

When was Zionism established? Around 1897.

Looks like it was a success in spreading among Christian churches.

The interlinear Bible shows no Jews mentioned in the Bible. It's translated word for word. The word Jew came up 300 years after the crucificion.

There were nations, heathens, and

I don't see how Israelis and Israelites have the same DNA.

DNA testing in Israel is banned.

Abraham is the father of Christians. He crossed the river from Babylon to Canaan. That doesn't make someone's ethnicity change. It's crossing over the river and crossing over to God. 56:45

https://www.bitchute.com/video/Y39Oq2a2Maqi/

YosefChaim's avatar

First DNA... the only traceable Jewish DNA is with Kohanim. 

Kohanim share a distinctive pattern on the Y chromosome, called the Cohen Modal Haplotype (CMH).

The Y chromosome is passed from father to son, just as the traditional status of a Kohen is inherited through the paternal line.

A significant proportion of self-identified Kohanim—especially among both Ashkenazi and Sephardi communities—belong to Y-chromosome haplogroup J1, although others belong to J2 and additional lineages.

Genetic studies estimate that many Kohanim trace their paternal ancestry to one or a small number of common male ancestors who lived roughly 2,500–3,500 years ago, a timeframe consistent with the biblical period. However, genetics cannot identify a specific individual such as Aaron.

Now to Zionism 

There are two very different groups 

Small z zionism

Capital Z Zionism 

Small z zionist... I am part of this group and 99% of Jews (except for the liberal Jewish university student who do not "want to be Jewish")

The desire for Jews to return to the Land of Israel is ancient and appears throughout the Hebrew Bible and Jewish prayers. For nearly 2,000 years after the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, many Jews maintained the hope of returning to Zion (Jerusalem and the Land of Israel).

Capital Z Zionism 

16 million Jews on earth with approximately 8 million being Capital Z Zionists.

In this case Zionism is no different than Democrat Communist Republican, Fascism, Socialism... political parties or ideologies.

In America there are approximately 40 - 60 million Christian capital Z Zionists.

Zionism emerged in the late 19th century, particularly in response to rising antisemitism and the growth of European nationalism.

1896: Der Judenstaat ("The Jewish State") was published by Theodor Herzl, laying out the case for establishing a Jewish state.

1897: The First Zionist Congress met in Basel, Switzerland, where delegates adopted the Basel Program, which sought "to establish a home for the Jewish people secured under public law." This is generally regarded as the formal founding of the modern Zionist movement.

Robert Wistedt's avatar

THEN WHY DO THESE FEW CONTROL OUR CONGRESS WITH AND AIPAC

and the BIDEN white house was full of JEWS why would we ever allow the ISRAEL

Military to JOIN out Military - why are we giving Billions to ISRAEL? of our TAX dollars = THEY ARE THE WORLD'S WORST ENEMY - ISRAEL LEADERS

Not your corner store JEW or neighbor here in the USA if they are AMERICA

FIRST, I stand with then - IF they are ISRAEL first, they need to GET the Hell

OUT of this COUNTRY !

YosefChaim's avatar

First you are talking to a generational US MIlitary vet who is Jewish.

I am MAGA... Independent but lean right. I too believe America first.

I dont believe in marrying our military with anyone... including NATO.

Israel is the only ally who will fight along side our military... that is a fact we all just witnessed.

Aid given to Israel is self serving aid. 181 nations receive some form of tax payer aid and ONLY Israel is REQUIRED to spend 100% of it on US goods and services... the other 180 can spend your money in any country for anything no strings attached.

The fight we are in is pointed at Israel

Questions

Why is Iran developing intercontinental missiles?

Iran claims and was subsequently offered all the 20% enriched uranium they could ever need, for energy, medical etc but refused...

And Arak, a heavy water reactor is only needed for one thing, nuclear weapons.

Put it all together and its not solely aimed at Israel... standard ballistic missiles reach Israel.

If you put your anti jew hatred away for 30 seconds you will see this more clearly.

And look at us today, we have been invaded not by Jews but but by Islam and "brown" people Mexico through northern South America. None of them are Jews.

Robert Wistedt's avatar

ZIONIST JEWS in the BIDEN admin were and are behind the, the open border!

to take conservatives out with non US citizen votes "FRAUD' votes

They want whites out and DEAD listen to Rabbi's who want whites dead !

Still trying to guess why they went to war with IRAN, Knowing they would

cause world wide energy shortage, and world economic collapse, food

shortage and starvation! There all about killing off the world's population,

to gain global control it seems !

YosefChaim's avatar

We agree on all your points but you are using a broad brush with Jews.

Are you responsible for Charlie Manson, Jeffrey Dahmer or Hitler Mussolini or the pedophile Priests... all white non Jews?

Myorkas should be in jail, like Schiff, Schumer, Liz Cheney, Pelosi & Biden... King Obama and Fauci a modern day Dr Mengele

All the Jews I know, 500 men in my Shul none of them disagree with what I wrote

Name me one Observant Rabbi who wants whites dead... you accused now name him or them

D D's avatar

Robertwisted is accurate.

Jeff Heard's avatar

My opinions are neither the result of any Zionist or Jew and I would say that, with limits of course, there is a great deal of truth to what A.George has said. The Jews have been referred to historically as “The People of The Book”. There is simply no book in all of human history like it and the children of Abraham/Sarah are the featured subject. 2,000 years of early history covered by eleven chapters in Genesis. The remaining 49 chapters of Genesis are all Abraham and His children almost without exception. Abraham, Moses, Elisha, every single prophet, Jesus and every New Testament writer had one thing in common; their ancestry and the place where they lived. All Jewish… all written from the land of Israel and the direct subject of all of this book is Jews. The New Testament of the Bible teaches that God cares for everyone and will love those that love Him. No religion in history has been more open or more generous then that which is written by these prophets of the Old Testament and expounded upon in the new. I am not a Jew, but I respect them highly because they are a focal point of God, in past, present and future. That alone I think justifies the opinion of Ms George.

Karen Cook's avatar

That was an amazing walk thru centuries of history. Sad that unfortunately there doesn’t seem to be a clear way forward for Israel to exist in a peaceful state. Too much hate by people, some of which are willing to die, who don’t want peace or appeasement.

Beyond Spin's avatar

Robert, no doubt, is getting hasbara money for his tripe. He's just regurgitating all the propaganda I was indoctrinated to believe as a Jew in the Jewish community I grew up in. That propaganda I wrote about in this blog:

The Lies Behind Modern Zionist Narratives

https://beyondspin.wordpress.com/2025/08/09/when-lies-become-ones-truth

This blog includes the following paragraph:

"...Yet, given what I noted above about 1948 and the more recent history of Gaza, so many modern Jewish Zionists adamantly believe that the only reason anyone hates them is that they are Jewish. That is because of what they believe, not because of what was done to Palestinians over the past 100 years. These modern Zionists somehow can’t comprehend how colonization, ethnic cleansing, occupation, murder, administrative detentions, etc., created an environment of animosity and vengeance. So, these Zionists believe that they’re not only without any sin but that they’re innocent victims. Their cognitive dissonance is off the charts. They not only believe the lies they’ve repeated so often; those lies have become the very foundation of their entire existence..."

Robert should be ashamed of himself for compromising his integrity for hasbara money.

Beyond Spin's avatar

Robert must be getting really great hasbara money for all this tripe. Regardless, the one book he should have read, but didn't, is Benny Morris's 1948 and After.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/0198279299

This book was also written before Morris became such a Zionist apologist. In this book, Morris goes through Israeli historical archives recorded during 1948 and dispels a lot of the prevailing Zionist myths. The main difference betw. Morris's book and Pappe's book, The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine, is that Morris argues that there was no Plan Dalet ("Plan D"). Otherwise, their conclusions were strikingly similar, with Morris acknowledging Israel committed the first sin.

When you're raised in a Jewish community, as I was, you just accept the revised historical narrative and mythology that you were indoctrinated to believe. So, when you actually start exploring the real history, it's quite shocking and disconcerting to realize what Zionist militia, only a few years after the Holocaust, did to another people. The Irgun and Stern Gang were especially immoral.

And contrary to Morris's position, recently discovered records detail how Zionist militias did coordinate their attacks on Palestinian villages.

Franklin O'Kanu's avatar

One thing I see not mentioned here is the Balfour Declaration and the imperial process surrounding it. In 1917, the British government expressed support for establishing a “national home for the Jewish people” in Palestine in a letter addressed to Lord Walter Rothschild. That declaration was later incorporated into the British Mandate, despite Britain’s competing wartime promises and the fact that an existing population was already living on the land: https://unorthodoxy.substack.com/p/the-polarizing-complexity-of-the-f06

This is a very important piece, but overall, it still ties into the greater agenda of national interests taking priority over the individual.

Israel, as the bigger and more powerful nation in this situation, is using whatever justification it wishes to occupy and control this land. But that cannot be separated from the Balfour Declaration, British imperial interests, Rothschild, and the political forces that helped create the modern arrangement in the first place.

From a historical propaganda perspective, I also think this is where taking the Bible literally may help fuel such conquests with dire consequences: https://unorthodoxy.substack.com/p/the-mythology-of-the-bible-and-the

But then again, that is similar to what happened with Americans and the Indians through Manifest Destiny. When the land, gold, or resources are there, the larger and more powerful country will eventually take them. It will then create a divine, moral, legal, or historical justification for why doing so was right.

LB (Little Birdie)'s avatar

The head of the nail..."When the land, gold, or RESOURCES are there, the larger and more powerful country (vis a vis a dictator, kjng, terrorists, political party or entity with the most power) will eventually take them. It will then create a divine, moral, legal, or historical justification for why doing so was right."

and the 'people' will suffer the consequences every time.

Roni's avatar

God bless you and Jill. Thank you a thousand fold

Lalie's avatar

Drs. Malone, As they say in Israel, Kol hakavod. Well done. I commend you for your exceptionally thoughtful, well-reasoned and scholarly attempt to analyze the very complex situation Israel faces with its neighbors.

I would like to add a comment regarding a sub topics you addressed briefly, and that is the notion of (Israeli) “settler violence”. This is a hot topic not only by external parties and observers, but within Israel.

Like all statistics, definitions and categories matter. “Settler violence” includes incidents where a settler (and I don’t like using that term) is attacked by a Palestinian and the settler defends himself.

So all defensive action is categorized as violence. The escalating numbers of settler violence incidents reflects the increasing number of attacks by Palestinians against Jews.

Of the total number of attacks, I believe the percentage of violent incidents initiated by Jewish settlers is less than 20 percent.

Much more astounding is that when Jews go to the Temple Mount in the Old City and pray (yes, pray) that is reported as settler violence.

Lastly a nudgy observation, without explanation, I noticed you went from identifying the biblical heartland (where over 80% of biblical history took place) as Judea and Samaria, to identifying it as the West Bank. Many people understand the history of the West Bank and how it became identified as such, but many more don’t. For those who don’t, it was Jordan who named it as such when they illegally occupied it beginning in 1948.

Finally, Drs. Malone, yours is the least expensive of my Substack subscriptions and I receive more articles from you than from numerous combined authors. I think increasing your subscription rate would be understandable by most subscribers. Or adding another subscription level for those who would welcome contributing more to your magnificent substack. I appreciate all your writing, but your homesteading articles strike a deep chord of exhilaration.

Gail Benton's avatar

What I've heard and seen is that it's the settlers that are attacking Palestinians, taking their homes, and destroying their crops and livestock.

"If I don't steal it, someone else will."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNqozQ8uaV8

That's how they're expanding.

Palestinians would be killed if attacking an Israeli.

I have a hunch how people in the U.S. would react if these things were happening here.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPK7fGP7TrE

Lalie's avatar

Al Jazeera is owned by Qatar, hardly an unbiased news source on this topic. Regardless these are two videos that prove absolutely nothing and utterly lack credibility. It's embarrassing to have them attached to such an incredibly thoughtful and well-reasoned essay by Drs. Malone.

Gail Benton's avatar

That's a "nice way" to ignore all sides of the story.

Are these the guys who you want to believe?

Is 60 Minutes a credible enough source?

https://youtu.be/FLUUUZWjfGk?t=179

Mary mallory's avatar

I agree to all but the increased subscription rate. Too many bills already.

Lalie's avatar

Perhaps simply another subscription level for those who'd like to support them further. Or a donate button!

John Guy's avatar

What does a nation do when the wolf is continually at the door? That is the question the Palestinian

were asking in 1948.

The 1948 Palestinian expulsion, known as the Nakba (or "catastrophe"), involved the mass displacement of over 700,000 Palestinian Arabs, the destruction of more than 500 villages, and the creation of a lasting refugee crisis during the creation of Israel.

Scale of Displacement: Between 700,000 and 750,000 Palestinians—roughly 80% of the Arab population in the area that became Israel—fled or were forced from their homes.

Destruction of Towns: Zionist paramilitaries and later Israeli forces depopulated and destroyed over 500 Palestinian villages and major urban neighborhoods.

Military Operations: Actions like Plan D (Dalet) and specific assaults (such as the Deir Yassin massacre) forced mass evacuations through combat, expulsions, and psychological warfare.

The Palestinian answer was resistance, but they lack the resource and experience to fight back that took time.

Source: https://www.un.org/unispal/about-the-nakba/

Gail Benton's avatar

It's sad the people won't even look at this.

Divide and rule

"Palestine is the moral dilemma of the world. If it isn't stopped, the way of Palestine will be the way of the world."

~Max Igan

Crowhouse

They're already in DC.

The triple crown coup.

The Bar Association

It's attorneys have infiltrated all 3 branches.

Have you noticed how violent criminals are put back in the streets?

And, blaming Biden judges.

People are easily manipulated by the best social engineers that money can buy.

And, who has most of the money?

The wanna-be rulers of the world

Barbara Williamson's avatar

The saddest part has been said by Golda Meir years ago (paraphrasing): There will be no peace until Muslims learn to love their children more than they hate the Jews.

I have seen film of very young Muslim children, who should be in school getting an education, squatting on the dirt floor of a shed and spending their entire day making bullets. Indoctrination from birth, and the determination to spread Islam worldwide by any means necessary, including murder, is pounded into them until no other thoughts will fit into their brains. So very sad…such a waste of youth. These beautiful innocent young lives molded into killing machines and learning to think of nothing but hate.

Chris's avatar

The problem seems more deep rooted than can be easily explained. Muslims seem to hate Jews because they hate what they look like in comparison to them. Foolish, uneducated, primitive underachievers. Where would the Middle East be without oil? Israel would continue to do well and lead, the Arab countries would sink into 4th world status of hunger and despair.

Gail Benton's avatar

When your whole family is killed, can't buy crayons or paper in prison camps (Gaza), and you're constantly abused, what does one expect?

I kind of think that it's a set-up with a child on dirt floors making bullets.

"By deception we will war."

The Israeli children are indoctrinated, as well. I've seen reports of them being taught to hate, and want to kill.

Here's a teacher that talks of what she was taught in schools growing up, and what she's now trying to teach what she's learned.

Part 2

https://youtu.be/EBAdpeJrN_Q?t=825

Gail Benton's avatar

Golda Meir also said she had a Palestinian passport.

There's a history that people haven't been taught.

By design.

Here's a Jewish professional talking about what he's learned.

https://youtu.be/ph9XF39yjgU?t=403

Dave Coleman's avatar

Thank you for all the work that went into this latest essay. Lots to consider, but you touched on a point I like to make to those (including some in my own family) harshly critical of Israel's actions and supportive of Hamas and the people of Gaza that support Hamas' actions. Namely, as the head of my family, if I were surrounded by neighbors that openly threatened to kill me, burn my house and rape my daughters, and there is no "sheriff" to keep order, what would I be justified in doing about it? There are those who see sinister motives: Why does Israel have such a strong lobby in Washington? Why do "the Jews" try to "buy" influence? Are the Israeli intelligence services up to no good? Are they sharing all their knowledge with us? Are they doing "bad things" that we don't know about, and that we do know about? and far worse accusations: genocide, duplicity, etc. My answer is, "I don't know all Israel does, and they may make errors, but I do know that if my family were constantly under threat of death, rape, and torture, I would do everything I could, legal or illegal, to protect them. Israel is not the bad guy here, and "existing" is not a justification for all the threats and violence leveled against them by their "neighbors." Every honest rational person knows what the source of the trouble is, and it's not Israel.

Fred Jewett's avatar

I posted this comment before but in light of your Israeli research it deserves repeating.

My Lebanese laundress explained to me one time that we in the West have NO CLUE as to how they think in the middle east. Their thinking process is totally foreign to western conceptualization.

To illustrate the point, I was at a party one time hosted by a missionary couple. They had spent time in the middle east and worked at a hospital. They ministered to an injured arab freedom fighter to give up his warlike ways. He readily agreed and said he would lead a peaceful life when he was well. After he was released they heard that the first thing he did was to get a rifle and rejoin his cadre.

Micheal Nash, Ph. D.'s avatar

Operative word there is culture. Not all are compatible with one another and it is pure unadulterated suicide for a culture to invite in one that is not compatible. Whi,h we are currently doing today

Gail Benton's avatar

Yes, our culture is being invaded, and the "other party" is doing nothing about indicting those that allowed/instigated it. So, I don't buy that it was "one party" that did it.

And, the infiltrated government is letting violent criminals back into society through fictional courts. A good way to create chaos, so the "government" can bring in draconian measures...total surveillance, federal RealID, military in the streets, etc.

The Palestinians "invited" the Jewish people after WWII into their homes.

They were locked out of their houses and threatened if they came back.

Then, 700,000 Palestinian refugees were rounded up in the 1948 Palestine war, and approximately 200,000 fled or were expelled to the Gaza Strip, where they settled in camps established in former British Army barracks.

That would be like all of Illinois rounded up into Cook county.

The remaining refugees dispersed to neighboring countries, primarily Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria, as well as the West Bank. The total number of displaced Palestinians is cited by historians and the UN as ranging between 700,000 and 750,000.

October 7th wasn't the start of a war.

https://youtu.be/ph9XF39yjgU?t=251

Gail Benton's avatar

One has to know the history that isn't being taught.

Who doesn't get to defend themselves?

https://youtu.be/ph9XF39yjgU?t=251

Toni Headen's avatar

Basically like street gangs. They revert to what is comfortable and where they are accepted. You need more than just a “pinky swear” to keep them on the right track. Money and effort needs to be placed on an alternate environment that supports their decision and even then it’s similar to an addiction. It can be tenuous at best. These are countries with problems dating back before Christ. The longer that the problems have been established the longer it will take to solve.

Gail Benton's avatar

One has to know the history that isn't being taught.

https://youtu.be/ph9XF39yjgU?t=251

Fred Jewett's avatar

Sorry I am not on facebook however I can understand the middle east Arabic nations hating the west as they have abused the middle east for centuries.

The Balfour Declartion of 1917, the occupation of Iran during world war two by the British and Soviets, the Partition Act of 1947, expulsion of the Palestinians in the 1950's, etc. I would be pissed off too.

Gail Benton's avatar

It's amazing how people just don't see it.

The war propaganda is successful.

Toni Headen's avatar

Most Americans barely know our history and the Middle East history is so much longer and so much more involved. These are all countries that have changed names and borders multiple times. And as they say history is written by the victorious and always makes the victorious look noble and just (occasionally they slip a little shady bit in there to keep it realistic) But just enough that anyone with empathy will say “Ohhhh. I understand I might do that too.” We’re just getting the Clif notes and told to pick a side (but not that side).

Robert Wistedt's avatar

The ZIONIST JEW'S are the world's worst ENEMY = world Domination globalists, watch Tucker

on the NATO BOTS and the plan to destroy anyone who is a Christian, Conservative, Not in line with

there Globalist world Domination Plans = Lead by Zionist JEW'S

Belloc's avatar

Don't forget about the Zionist Christians who aid and abet them. They are traitors to Christ and all other Christians. Ted Cruz and Mike Huckabee come to mind.

https://thejasonjonesshow.substack.com/p/jewish-terrorism-and-the-shame-of?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fa08690cc-943e-4b24-b22a-3751dc196ae6_860x574.jpeg&open=false

Theresa Holmes's avatar

Fascinating--and painful--analysis. Thank you for all the hard work you've put into this analysis.

(Just got "Homesteading for Health," BTW, and am looking forward to reading it.)

I have no "solutions" to suggest--because the only solutions that will ever work depend on every individual deciding whether to grow up, accept the existence of Reality as a Whole, Infinite and Eternal (by whatever Name, Title, or Descriptor one chooses to use), and ones place within Him as a unique and wonderful Point of View for Him--or go on rejecting His very existence WITHOUT WHICH THEY COULD NOT EXIST!

Acceptance leads to adulthood, in which we work together with respect as equals to resolve our inevitable disagreements and disputes to win-win-win solutions. We walk on the Bright Side of the Golden Rule, stated as "You do to others as you expect them to do to you." Because we do not expect to be attacked, we are very reluctant even to defend ourselves when we are attacked.

Rejection leads to perpetual insane toddlerhood. Those choosing this path lock themselves, usually AS TODDLERS, into tiny, self-centered worldviews that see everyone and everything outside as existential threats, to be controlled or eliminated. They walk on the Dark Side of the Golden Rule. Because they expect to be attacked, they choose to attack first.

All I can say is it's up to each of us to choose acceptance or rejection of Reality as a Whole and our places in Him. We are all players on His Stage, trying to figure out what parts we're to play using the Stanislavsky Method (go look it up), working with Him and each other, or against Him and all others within His Story. He has this, because only He knows the full Story He is telling through us.

I'll leave it at that.

Dr. Robert W. Malone's avatar

Thanks for buying the book and for subscribing!

Belloc's avatar

I respect this extremely well written essay with dozens of references cited to back it up (as only a scientist would do), but the flip side to this problem is that Israel is the wolf at our door. They have slowly worked on taking over our government through AIPAC funding and Christian Zionism which is an anachronism. In the 1920s they came up with the term "Judeo-Christian" to effectuate a mental shift within the American psyche. We were not founded by Jews. We were founded by devout Protestants and one Irish Roman Catholic.

Then they proceed to own everything in the US that can influence the public...our politicians, more politicians that have daul citizenship, all media companies, and the entertainment industry. The Mossad has been embedded with the CIA since the 1960s at least. Charlie Kirk lost his life because he said no to Netanyahu's money and began to reject Jewish donors million dollar checks to TPUSA because Charlie was America first, not Israel first.

I'm not contending that Israel shouldn't look out for Israel. But they sure as heck shouldn't spy on us, use our blood and treasure (our servicemen and women) to achieve their goals which is their blood feud with Iran and their intent for the Greater Israel Project. Interestingly enough, Israel outlaws all familial genetic testing. Why? Because the crew running Israel...Ben Gvir and Netanyahu wouldn't even be shown to be ethnically Jewish 100 per cent.

An Australian ambassador recently spoke before the UN about the IDFs treatment of a young teen boy they killed for sport. A friend of mine has a nursing friend that was doing a doctor's without borders trip in Gaza and she barely escaped with her life. The IDF came into the NICU they had set up and told the main doctor to leave immediately or he would be dead. The doctor refused so the IDF assassinated him on the spot, then sent the rest of the nurses and staff running while unplugging all the incubators so the babies would die.

I get my information from Jason Jones of the Vulnerable People Project, who is a good friend of Steve Bannon's. He has been on the ground for the last 2 years helping the people in Gaza and witnessing the atrocities committed by the IDF. In Lebanon, they are doing the same but actually got caught internationally chopping up a statue of the Blessed Virgin Mary. So I disagree, this isn't about protection, this is about an agenda because they are unaliving and persecuting Christians as well. This situation has gone WAY beyond self defense and yes an ethnic minority is capable of genocide.

Gail Benton's avatar

They've been the wolf at the door of Palestinians since 1948.

"By deception we will war."

And, now at the door of Christians?

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Br916Vy5uuA

Belloc's avatar

I've seen other information about the genocide Israel is perpetrating against Lebanon. It's heartbreaking. So what is the damn reason for that? They say the threat of Hamas within Lebanon and yet Ben-Gvir, who is human garbage, said "we will bathe in the tears of thousands of Lebanese mothers". Like ole Jacob666, Ben Gvir thinks they are a master race. The only master of their ethnicity (because Judaism isn't a race. 🤦‍♀️) that ever walked the earth was Jesus Christ, and we saw what happened then. Christians became God's chosen people when Jews outright rejected Christ as the Messiah. Full stop.

Roy Schneider is an Orthodox Jew who converted to Catholicism. I saw him speak at a Catholic conference and he handed out prayer cards asking for the intercession of St Edith Stein, another Jewish convert to Catholicism during WW2, for the conversion of the Jews to Christianity.

The problem with my Church is that it's so woke in the hierarchy. You have a Pope saying heretical things about Islam being holy and pretty much ignoring the Netanayhu and the greater Israel Project. He loves bashing Trump but doesn't say a word about what Israel is doing to Lebanon. My prayer group prays every night that this madness ends.

And also Jacob666 claiming Jews are the salvation of the United States is laughable. They are a supplicant or vassal state as Bannon calls them. They are sucking us dry like a parasite. US taxpayers give so much money to Israel (a country of 10 million) that everyone has free education, healthcare and housing. As Charlie Kirk said before assassination...they fit the stereotype for a reason.

People like Jacob are triggered because the United States is beginning to learn the Truth, as much as the media has tried to shield them from it.

Jacob99's avatar

"Interestingly enough, Israel outlaws all familial genetic testing. Why" Good question ? What do you guess? You could ask any AI:

"1. Protection Against Mamzer Status under Jewish Law The primary driver behind Israel's strict regulation of paternity and paternity-adjacent DNA testing is religious and civil law regarding personal status. Israel’s family law for Jewish citizens is governed by Rabbinical courts. Under Orthodox Halakha (Jewish religious law), a child born from an adulterous relationship involving a married Jewish woman is classified as a mamzer.A person classified as a mamzer and their descendants are severely restricted under Jewish law and cannot legally marry another Jewish Israeli (other than another mamzer or a convert). To prevent children from being designated as mamzerim, Israeli law intentionally makes it difficult to conduct casual or unapproved paternity tests that might accidentally reveal extra-marital paternity. Courts often refuse to order a paternity test if there is a risk it will label a child a mamzer."

However, FYI, many Jews , about 40-50 % in Israel are ashkenazi Jews. I guess most of them came from what used to be the Russian empire. I came from the USSR, live in US. I did have 23andMe test. It told me that I'm 99% ashkenazi Jew. I guess this is what this tells about the majority of Russian Jews who live in Israel. So please stop repeating random stupidity generated by Tucker Carlson and think for yourself.

"Ben Gvir and Netanyahu wouldn't even be shown to be ethnically Jewish 100 per cent"

Ben Gvir parents were Mizrahi Jews originally from Iraq.

In any case why does it matter?

King David was an Israelite from the tribe of Judah, but he was not 100% Israelite by strict ancestry because his great-grandmother, Ruth, was a Moabite.

"An Australian ambassador recently spoke before the UN about the IDFs treatment of a young teen boy they killed for sport."

An Australian official did not speak before the United Nations about this; rather, independent Australian Senator David Pocock quoted a United Nations report inside the Australian Parliament regarding IDF actions.

So you can't even correctly write about "An Australian ambassador" I doubt that you correctly transmitted info about "a friend of mine has a nursing friend that was doing a doctor's without borders trip in Gaza and she barely escaped with her life."

Belloc's avatar

I'm not repeating random stupidity Zionist. You and Laura Loomer are not a master race. And your people are genociding Christians and Muslims. Why are you Zionist Jews so freakin arrogant and intellectual obtuse. You're not superior, you're insecure and cry victim on one hand and we're superior on the other. And you and Loomer are so incredibly alone and sad.

Jacob99's avatar

I'm not a crying victim , we are superior.

KGB Officer: "Haim, where do you get all your money?"

Haim: "From the nightstand (tumbochka)!"

KGB Officer: "And who puts the money in the nightstand?"

Haim: "My wife, Sarah!"

KGB Officer: "And where does Sarah get the money from?"

Haim: "From me!"

KGB Officer (losing his temper): "And where do YOU get the money from?!"

Haim: "Are you deaf? I told you—from the nightstand!"

"Haim, stop playing games with us! The Soviet state has existed for over 50 years, and it will last forever! Where do you get this money, and how do you think this will end?!"

Haim sighs deeply and says:

"Look, major... Once upon a time, Pharaoh ruled Egypt. He oppressed the Jews, built pyramids, and tried to destroy us. Today, where is Pharaoh? Gone. Where are the pyramids? In ruins. But the Jews are still here.

Then came the Roman Empire. Caesar oppressed the Jews, destroyed the Temple, and tried to wipe us out. Where is Caesar? Gone. Where is Rome? In ruins. But the Jews are still here.

Now we have the Soviet Union..."

KGB Officer (gritting his teeth):

"What are you trying to say, Haim?!"

Haim winks:

"I’m just saying... we’re in the final stage!"

================

I guess not yet. We have to save America from the union of national socialists and international socialists

Belloc's avatar

You're an idiot Jacob. And you're triggered because the American public is finally on to your Pravda. Now go look in the mirror and keep filling your head full of delusions. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Jacob99's avatar

At least one of us is an idiot, maybe we are both idiots. But I'm a superior idiot. We are the best at everything.

Belloc's avatar

This is my last comment because you bore me. You are an insecure, effeminate Jewish male with delusions of grandeur. Why are all the Jewish men in positions of power short and effeminate? 🤔

You keep telling yourself whatever you need to, to maintain that fragile psyche of yours. Byeeeeeeeee 😂

Dan Harrison's avatar

Drs. RWM & JGM, Your writing is extraordinary and appropriate for the time. I read your “PsyWar” book, when will you write a book on the aspects of: Situational awareness, Authority gradient, breaking unanimity, ‘God lives in the details’, premortem, ‘the Sheriff is absent’, preemptive killing, imminent vs. existential threat, Supreme emergency, Moral residue, etc. …?

Dan Harrison

Dr. Robert W. Malone's avatar

This Israel series is pretty much a short book issued in installments. Thanks for supporting our work. In terms of formal book publications, "Homesteading for Health" is now shipping, and "The Chronic Rebellion" and "The Grift" are both in an advanced stage of development. We have lost our publisher (Skyhorse) and are now negotiating for a new one.

Toni Headen's avatar

My problem is how do we determine which genocides/atrocities to help and which to ignore? Which ones do we lavish our military and (unlimited tax payer!?!) funds on? Who wins the lottery and what is the criteria? Why do we just shrug our shoulders 🤷🏻‍♀️at small African and asian countries but throw all that we have behind Israel? Are they more deserving than Nigeria? Cambodia against the Kmer Rouge? As always the answer is “Follow the money or natural resources” (which we will then turn into profit).

Teresa's avatar

The United States government modus operandi is to take from other countries the things we want. Always under the guise of Peace. I feel like I'm living in 1984. Trump's threats change daily. Yesterday, he said he would have the Iranians decapitated. Our government has become the world's bully.

beccar1954's avatar

The money coming from Iran to Gaza is drying up. Other Arab states now have aligned with the US against Iran and are willing to coexist with Israel. Maybe, just maybe, there is a chance for peace. There is a fundamental realignment going on that could be a light at the end of the tunnel.

D D's avatar

Just a note about "intuitions" vs institutions?

Dr. Robert W. Malone's avatar

nit has been picked....