25 Comments
User's avatar
anna george's avatar

An amazing read! Thank you for what must have been days to put together.

Historical content to which I had no idea nor any way to ever get. We Americans do Not understand either these people or what they are forced to do to simply survive. I’ll never understand the hatred of the Jewish people. Why? They appear to be “regular people”, have a religion that goes back centuries but other countries want them gone which will never happen. They are God’s chosen. Sadly, it just has to be demonic.

Robert Wistedt's avatar

They are NOT god's Chosen = just another Zionist JEW lie like the HOHOHOAX !

D D's avatar

Robertwisted is accurate.

Roni's avatar

God bless you and Jill. Thank you a thousand fold

ComeQuicklyLord's avatar

Thank you for the Audio and Written transcript. These essays have been thought provoking.

Israel turned over Gaza to its occupants in 2005, which included functioning green houses, that provided Israel and Europe with vegetables, to include watermelon—it was a multi-million dollar business, which Israeli’s were forced to abandon.

As soon as the Israelis left, the green houses, synagogues, and other buildings were systematically destroyed, out of pure hatred for the Jewish people. When they realized they destroyed an an agricultural and rvonomic opportunity they asked Israel to help rebuild them—crickets, for just reasons.

After receiving billions of dollars of International Aide, instead of building a robust economy and infrastructure, they created, IMO, the world’s largest welfare state, and a structure that foments hatred toward the Jewish people, and America.

They could have created a government that openly trades with Israel, but did not, and IMO, still refuses to do so. How can a person, let alone a government, help those who refuse to grow and thrive on their own, but rather, insists on your destruction? Hatred and envy are destructive behaviors.

May God grant Israel and the United States wisdom to maneuver through this political and ideological mine field.

Dr. Robert W. Malone's avatar

Very difficult moral landscape

Theresa Holmes's avatar

Fascinating--and painful--analysis. Thank you for all the hard work you've put into this analysis.

(Just got "Homesteading for Health," BTW, and am looking forward to reading it.)

I have no "solutions" to suggest--because the only solutions that will ever work depend on every individual deciding whether to grow up, accept the existence of Reality as a Whole, Infinite and Eternal (by whatever Name, Title, or Descriptor one chooses to use), and ones place within Him as a unique and wonderful Point of View for Him--or go on rejecting His very existence WITHOUT WHICH THEY COULD NOT EXIST!

Acceptance leads to adulthood, in which we work together with respect as equals to resolve our inevitable disagreements and disputes to win-win-win solutions. We walk on the Bright Side of the Golden Rule, stated as "You do to others as you expect them to do to you." Because we do not expect to be attacked, we are very reluctant even to defend ourselves when we are attacked.

Rejection leads to perpetual insane toddlerhood. Those choosing this path lock themselves, usually AS TODDLERS, into tiny, self-centered worldviews that see everyone and everything outside as existential threats, to be controlled or eliminated. They walk on the Dark Side of the Golden Rule. Because they expect to be attacked, they choose to attack first.

All I can say is it's up to each of us to choose acceptance or rejection of Reality as a Whole and our places in Him. We are all players on His Stage, trying to figure out what parts we're to play using the Stanislavsky Method (go look it up), working with Him and each other, or against Him and all others within His Story. He has this, because only He knows the full Story He is telling through us.

I'll leave it at that.

Dr. Robert W. Malone's avatar

Thanks for buying the book and for subscribing!

Franklin O'Kanu's avatar

One thing I see not mentioned here is the Balfour Declaration and the imperial process surrounding it. In 1917, the British government expressed support for establishing a “national home for the Jewish people” in Palestine in a letter addressed to Lord Walter Rothschild. That declaration was later incorporated into the British Mandate, despite Britain’s competing wartime promises and the fact that an existing population was already living on the land: https://unorthodoxy.substack.com/p/the-polarizing-complexity-of-the-f06

This is a very important piece, but overall, it still ties into the greater agenda of national interests taking priority over the individual.

Israel, as the bigger and more powerful nation in this situation, is using whatever justification it wishes to occupy and control this land. But that cannot be separated from the Balfour Declaration, British imperial interests, Rothschild, and the political forces that helped create the modern arrangement in the first place.

From a historical propaganda perspective, I also think this is where taking the Bible literally may help fuel such conquests with dire consequences: https://unorthodoxy.substack.com/p/the-mythology-of-the-bible-and-the

But then again, that is similar to what happened with Americans and the Indians through Manifest Destiny. When the land, gold, or resources are there, the larger and more powerful country will eventually take them. It will then create a divine, moral, legal, or historical justification for why doing so was right.

LB (Little Birdie)'s avatar

The head of the nail..."When the land, gold, or RESOURCES are there, the larger and more powerful country (vis a vis a dictator, kjng, terrorists, political party or entity with the most power) will eventually take them. It will then create a divine, moral, legal, or historical justification for why doing so was right."

and the 'people' will suffer the consequences every time.

D D's avatar

Just a note about "intuitions" vs institutions?

Dr. Robert W. Malone's avatar

nit has been picked....

Dan Harrison's avatar

Drs. RWM & JGM, Your writing is extraordinary and appropriate for the time. I read your “PsyWar” book, when will you write a book on the aspects of: Situational awareness, Authority gradient, breaking unanimity, ‘God lives in the details’, premortem, ‘the Sheriff is absent’, preemptive killing, imminent vs. existential threat, Supreme emergency, Moral residue, etc. …?

Dan Harrison

Dr. Robert W. Malone's avatar

This Israel series is pretty much a short book issued in installments. Thanks for supporting our work. In terms of formal book publications, "Homesteading for Health" is now shipping, and "The Chronic Rebellion" and "The Grift" are both in an advanced stage of development. We have lost our publisher (Skyhorse) and are now negotiating for a new one.

Fred Jewett's avatar

I posted this comment before but in light of your Israeli research it deserves repeating.

My Lebanese laundress explained to me one time that we in the West have NO CLUE as to how they think in the middle east. Their thinking process is totally foreign to western conceptualization.

To illustrate the point, I was at a party one time hosted by a missionary couple. They had spent time in the middle east and worked at a hospital. They ministered to an injured arab freedom fighter to give up his warlike ways. He readily agreed and said he would lead a peaceful life when he was well. After he was released they heard that the first thing he did was to get a rifle and rejoin his cadre.

Ross Bausone's avatar

After only reading the opening of Part 3, my initial answer is: A Wolf is a predator. If it's at the door, it has one intent. Therefore my intent is to Kill the Wolf! End of story!

John Guy's avatar

What does a nation do when the wolf is continually at the door? That is the question the Palestinian

were asking in 1948.

The 1948 Palestinian expulsion, known as the Nakba (or "catastrophe"), involved the mass displacement of over 700,000 Palestinian Arabs, the destruction of more than 500 villages, and the creation of a lasting refugee crisis during the creation of Israel.

Scale of Displacement: Between 700,000 and 750,000 Palestinians—roughly 80% of the Arab population in the area that became Israel—fled or were forced from their homes.

Destruction of Towns: Zionist paramilitaries and later Israeli forces depopulated and destroyed over 500 Palestinian villages and major urban neighborhoods.

Military Operations: Actions like Plan D (Dalet) and specific assaults (such as the Deir Yassin massacre) forced mass evacuations through combat, expulsions, and psychological warfare.

The Palestinian answer was resistance, but they lack the resource and experience to fight back that took time.

Source: https://www.un.org/unispal/about-the-nakba/

D D's avatar

I'll just write a short comment now, before reading this more carefully. I keep wondering about the impact of Post Traumatic effects on all the children, the returning soldiers and the rest of the civilians from these acts of violence all these years. It has to be affecting us all in one way or another. Unless we find a way to instruct how to cope and heal, the cumulative effects are traumatic in itself. Certainly the V. A. has done a poor job as well as our military and the rest of the military worldwide. It seems to me to be a priority to address this situation.

Dr. Robert W. Malone's avatar

PTSD treatment is a hot topic in israel. New methods are being developed. We saw some amazing progress being done using hyperbaric oxygen

D D's avatar

I am so glad to hear this, I read somewhere yesterday that funding or support was being downsized in the military.

David Merrill's avatar

"There is no simple, clean answer."

I keep hammering Problem Identification.

Here's what you got, Robert - a global spiritual apocalypse, already immanent. You and Jill were witness to a good taste of the first wave. As above so below, we experience cycles - in this case, 2,520 years. I predicted the onset of Intifada to the day.

"An intifada is an Arabic word meaning "uprising" or "shaking off", most widely known in English as the two major Palestinian protests and resistance movements against the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip.The First Intifada (1987–1993)" I call it Daniel Calendar.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1frNIMV97X50HF789ED5MBJTvGJTJoJe5

PROPHECY FOR 2026

https://davidmerrill.substack.com/p/prophecy-for-2026

The reasoning about karma is simple. Esau has been cheated by extortion and fraud (Rebecca and Isaac swindle) Isaiah and the bloodlines tell us that Idumean blood made confluence into the Dragon genome with Jesus CHRIST as King of Judea for one week. (Who ordered end to child blood sacrifice in the Temple, even collapsed a money market around it and had to feign his own execution to escape. With this lesson learned, TRUMP and RFK Jr are wise to head in fast and then slow down.)

One Daniel Cycle ago however, note in my SubStack article linked, we find the newly created Jew finishing his conquest of the Holy Land. The Daniel Calendar chart linked above demonstrates the signing of our First Constitution found in Nehemiah 10. A formal reading and notice of the Law - the Laws of Moses FRCP being Exodus 20-24:7.

The Apocalypse of Faith.

lynn's avatar

Well articulated analysis

I follow the premise of another author from another book.

The final chapters on planet earth God's people and the land of Israel will be vindicated.

Zechariah 14

Robert Wistedt's avatar

The ZIONIST JEW'S are the world's worst ENEMY = world Domination globalists, watch Tucker

on the NATO BOTS and the plan to destroy anyone who is a Christian, Conservative, Not in line with

there Globalist world Domination Plans = Lead by Zionist JEW'S

Barbara Williamson's avatar

The saddest part has been said by Golda Meir years ago (paraphrasing): There will be no peace until Muslims learn to love their children more than they hate the Jews.

I have seen film of very young Muslim children, who should be in school getting an education, squatting on the dirt floor of a shed and spending their entire day making bullets. Indoctrination from birth, and the determination to spread Islam worldwide by any means necessary, including murder, is pounded into them until no other thoughts will fit into their brains. So very sad…such a waste of youth. These beautiful innocent young lives molded into killing machines and learning to think of nothing but hate.

Dave Coleman's avatar

Thank you for all the work that went into this latest essay. Lots to consider, but you touched on a point I like to make to those (including some in my own family) harshly critical of Israel's actions and supportive of Hamas and the people of Gaza that support Hamas' actions. Namely, as the head of my family, if I were surrounded by neighbors that openly threatened to kill me, burn my house and rape my daughters, and there is no "sheriff" to keep order, what would I be justified in doing about it? There are those who see sinister motives: Why does Israel have such a strong lobby in Washington? Why do "the Jews" try to "buy" influence? Are the Israeli intelligence services up to no good? Are they sharing all their knowledge with us? Are they doing "bad things" that we don't know about, and that we do know about? and far worse accusations: genocide, duplicity, etc. My answer is, "I don't know all Israel does, and they may make errors, but I do know that if my family were constantly under threat of death, rape, and torture, I would do everything I could, legal or illegal, to protect them. Israel is not the bad guy here, and "existing" is not a justification for all the threats and violence leveled against them by their "neighbors." Every honest rational person knows what the source of the trouble is, and it's not Israel.