Hello Robert.. there were antibodies to the bird flue… yes indeed a whole herd of ostrich that were gunned down by the Canadian government… they had got the flue… and survived… the owners begged for a chance to use their antibodies.. nope… can’t have that. Log into Rebel News… they did a whole documentary about that fiasco…
You’ve(Dr. Malone) has hit on a core critique that many agro-ecologists and small-scale farmers share. There are many folks on the Good Doctor's side...
There is a deep asymmetry in how public and private funding is allocated:
Billions flow into high-tech, proprietary lab interventions, while very little supports the systematic study of field-level resilience.
By shifting the lens away from hyper-isolated laboratory models and toward actual operational farms, several critical insights emerge about how birds build resistance under ordinary conditions.
********************************
The Field-Level Blind Spot: What the Labs Miss
When geneticists try to engineer disease resistance in a lab, they typically look for a single "switch"—a specific protein receptor or gene sequence (like ANP32A, a common target for CRISPR research) that they can alter to block the virus.
However, real-world immunity is rarely a single switch. Birds thriving in ordinary, less-industrialized farm environments often rely on a complex web of factors that labs struggle to replicate:
• Polygenic Immunity: Real-world resistance is usually polygenic—meaning it is driven by dozens of minor genetic variations working in tandem across the bird's entire immune system. Because this architecture is incredibly complex and hard to patent, it receives far less corporate research funding than a clean, single-gene edit.
• The Microbiome and Environmental Micro-Dosing: Birds raised on varied terrain, with access to diverse forage, soil, and sunlight, develop vastly different gut and respiratory microbiomes than those raised in sterile, climate-controlled barns. In ordinary farm settings, flocks are continuously exposed to low-pathogenic, mild strains of avian viruses brought in by wild birds. This constant "micro-dosing" can prime their immune systems, giving them a level of adaptive resilience that a lab-raised, pathogen-free chicken completely lacks.
• Epigenetics: Lab studies often ignore epigenetics—how environmental stressors or benefits alter gene expression across generations. A maternal hen that survives environmental challenges passes down specific antibodies and epigenetic markers to her chicks, a natural multi-generational defense mechanism that is severed in industrial hatcheries.
***************************************
If there are birds thriving under ordinary conditions, why isn't the agricultural establishment studying them to scale up solutions?
1. The Conflict with "Maximum Yield"
The primary barrier is that the industrial poultry industry operates on microscopic financial margins. The birds are bred strictly for maximum feed-to-meat conversion rates or extreme egg-laying frequencies.
When researchers observe "thriving" birds on ordinary or diversified farms, those birds are almost always heritage breeds, landraces, or mixed crosses. These birds allocate a significant portion of their biological energy toward maintaining a robust immune system. In the eyes of industrial integrators, that energy is "wasted"—it's energy that isn't being converted into breast meat or daily eggs. The industry has historically been unwilling to accept even a 5% drop in production efficiency in exchange for natural disease resistance.
2. The Data Collection Gap
Because the USDA's default protocol for highly pathogenic avian influenza is immediate eradication, we actually destroy the very data that could save the industry. When a farm is struck by H5N1, the entire flock is culled within 24 to 48 hours.
This means we rarely give nature the chance to show us who would survive. If 95% of a flock dies but 5% possesses a natural genetic immunity, those 5% are culled right along with the rest to satisfy trade regulations. We are actively throwing away the biological roadmap to natural resistance because the regulatory framework doesn’t allow for the observation of survivors.
********************************
Some independent researchers and veterinary ecologists advocate for a shift toward "agro-ecological surveillance." Instead of trying to force a fragile, monoculture bird to survive in a high-density barn through genetic engineering, this approach suggests:
1. Mapping Survivor Flocks: Systematically genotyping small, backyard, or pasture-based flocks that were exposed to wild migratory birds carrying H5N1 but did not succumb to the disease.
2. Decentralized Breeding Hubs: Funding regional breeding hubs that select for robust, all-around health and structural soundness rather than a singular production metric.
3. Rethinking the Biosecurity Paradigm: Moving away from the idea that absolute sterility is the only safety. True safety may lie in biological diversity—both in the genetics of the birds and the ecosystems they live in.
A farmer friend once said to me regarding field science vs lab science: what is shown in the field can be replicated in the lab, but what is shown in the lab can't necessarily be replicated in the field. Very, very true.
The first tenet of science is OBSERVATION. And while one farmer's observations may not apply across the whole domain of agriculture, if the observation is studied out, especially if a handful of farmers have the same observation, it is a worthy project. Basically a case-series in the medical epidemiologic terminology. Perhaps very low on the worshipped "evidence-based science" paradigm, but one not to be dismissed.
Anyone comes on your property from any government agency you are entitled to:
Ask for ID and be shown that ID.
Read, examine and get copies of any paperwork or relevant laws as to why said officials are there.
Limit the scope of their entry or intrusion.
Have a supervisor respond to the scene.
Exceptions are warrants, fresh pursuit and exigent circumstances.
Be leery of non Police officialdom that enters and demands things. They are probably wrong. As a Sgt. went to extensive and ongoing training about search and seizure. Most officials and many attorneys have no clue what is legal and above board or not.
Still have 13 assorted chickens on our homestead. No one is killing them except my wife or the occasional bird that gets eaten by a coyote.
Anything designed by mankind in laboratories is to be questioned. Dr Malone's chickens are fed well and are out in nature; and are healthy. My father raised 5 children without medicine or medical assistance...and we were all here, until a brother took the vax in 2022 in order to travel. I am 92...and don't use any medication. I do use very specific food supplements; not coming from commercial drug stores.
RIGHT ON! I don't play The Doktor Game either. I was so proud to get my AA degree in Medical Assisting more than forty years ago. Working in medical offices and hospitals opened my eyes. I never went back ... so far so good ... I'm 87 and counting.
How about sharing the names and where you get waid food supplements!!! You have some very good genes. So the vax got your brother? Wow. Who CAN we trust?
This is why we don't let any 'official' organization know about the chickens we may or may not have in the family. The birds are all doing fine. The testing is not really telling you anything meaningful. I feed the outdoor birds (jays, sparrows, whatever flies to my feeders) because I actually DO support wild bird populations in my area.
There are enough invasive predators (house cats) that my neighbors have (and I get it, they love the company and the rodent control), that I try to be the counter balance to the environment and try to keep my native bird populations going strong. We had wildfires this Summer that took out a lot of the forest lands, I think that really drove the jays down to my part of our canyon. I am not worried about H5N1. I have seen this story too many times in my 70 years of biochemical research. Maybe I will be when I am 90 and immune compromised, but I am also good with the good Lord taking me when it's my time. Just sayin'...
As a veterinarian and a backyard flock owner who lives not too far from H5N1 epicenter of Athens, GA, the culling makes me sick to my stomach.
They always throw up one study from Africa in the 2000s that had 100% mortality. Sample size was tiny and they were experimentally infected.
I have layers and we have free roaming games that eat our Georgia ticks. I have lost one or two chickens here and there to respiratory disease, but never had a flock die off or even a total flock illness.
My games are free roaming.....they kill each other occasionally, but they are very healthy.
My layers occasionally have issues because they are not free roaming, but the issues are mild and they all live at least 6 or 7 years with no intervention other than hot pepper flakes.
I think the reasons for any flu issues in commercial operations are due to overcrowding and poor ventilation.....want a recipe for respiratory disease in ANY species? There ya go.
I have never tested any of my birds and never will.
My layers are molting right now, so very few eggs.
The culling is also a racket. This big producers get reimbursed for killing the flock if they have a positive test......so.
Is it possible that eating naturally disease resistant food, be it animal or vegetable, would help the consumer of the food become more disease resistant as well?
Mankind lived thousands of years on natural unprocessed food...The Processed Foods have little value...They provide calories and fill the stomach, but actually rob the body of nutrients being digested. For 65 years, i have researched health and nutrition and at 92 I am healthier than I was a 30. I take no medication. Hippocrates, the Father of Medicine, was known for his cures. He prescribed natural food, and said exercise was equally as important as food...so I do almost 2 hours of non-stop walking daily in the fresh air and sunlight. These are things he prescribed. Good health comes from very simple things.
I admire your dedication to maintaining good health by feeding your body with natural foods containing nutrients we need. Walking in sunshine, fresh air is a major part of longevity. Here’s to many more productive years!
Thank you! I follow Hippocrates, The Father of Medicine, who was known for his cures. He used the word Medicine to mean Food. He said, "Let Food be your medicine; and Medicine be Your Food." How did the Medical Industry come up with toxic lab-created items and calling them medicine? He also said that exercise was equally as important as food. Hippocrates teachings are not taught in Medical Schools...Guess its not interested in cures!
During the course of giving scores of talks to organic farmers and veterinary groups, I have always said that the basis to immunity is sunshine, fresh air, clean water, dry bedding and species-appropriate food. With that (and not being crammed into barracks by the thousands), the immune system can function as God intended.
Another great article by y’all. The question of why not use common sense animal husbandry (in terms of breeding for resistance) versus glamorous animal science (genetic editing, genetic vaccines, etc) is simple: money. There is no money for companies to make in animal husbandry (well, not much) compared to the billions in the pharma-university-regulatory complex. I know you guys know that but that is simply the truth. It’s the p<.05 crowd versus common sense.
The other thing is that even though we certainly could and should breed for resistance, cramming thousands of birds into industrial poultry houses creates very fragile “eco-systems”, where people have to shower-in and suit up to go in (like huge hog houses, too). Basically, the USDA is most interested in creating the cheapest food possible for the most people with science that worships the mighty p<.05 and rewards companies with grants that can patent products to support such systems.
American ag has become dependent on science that supports essentially well-fed and well-medicated concentration camps.
Animal husbandry is for the people. Animal science is for the companies.
Thanks for yet another readable, article that shares important information. Your sharing of the knowledge you researched and live with is a gift of caring for mankind.
When you crowd 10,000 chickens into a confined space without sun light and the chickens do not have personal space, their immune system goes to h*ll in a hand basket! The clever design of mass production of chickens and eggs is the root cause. So, susceptibility to infections such as bird flu is the result. Change the farming practices and the problem is solved.
Wanton destruction. At the top of my list was the evil destruction of a population of ostriches in Canada. Apparenty recovered and healthy. With several viable options.
Development of plants by breeding has been encouraged over the years. Why not birds/chickens? Is the answer the pharma opportunities? Natures answers benefit the birds and their owners. Industry answers benefit corporations and investors. In the end, who shoulders the impacts and costs - the farmers, customers and the birds.
A part of my higher education was devoted to animal husbandry. Even chicken breeding and management. My experiences at the zoo in the bird dept never touched on diseases, nor wild bird caused infections.
I couldn't be more in favor of studying, selecting and pursuing breeding that occasions disease resistance. As a taxpayer I vote for this type of use of our moneys!
Thank you muchly for covering this valuable discussion again!
We have fed wild birds for well over a 50 yr span at 3 different locations in Texas and never been diagnosed with bird flu. Testing our serum for that bug might be interesting tho.
Your article about breeding chickens that can survive bird flu reminded me of an old story from France. It's something I've been looking into lately.
During World War I, a French surgeon named Pierre Delbet was treating soldiers with infected wounds. This was long before antibiotics, when a serious infection could easily cost a man his life. Delbet became interested in magnesium chloride and its effects on white blood cells. He wondered whether doctors could do more to help the body fight back.
Years later, another French physician, Auguste Neveu, came across his work. Neveu had served as a medical officer in the French Navy and graduated at the top of his medical class in Bordeaux.
In the 1930s, Neveu began trying out Delbet's ideas in practice, including on sick animals. Two cases appear in the old accounts: a dog suffering from distemper and a calf with foot-and-mouth disease. Both reportedly recovered after being given magnesium chloride. Neveu was particularly insistent about starting treatment at the very first signs of illness.
Did magnesium chloride actually save those animals? I wish we knew. Those accounts alone can't tell us.
But I find the story fascinating, especially when I think about your chickens.
Neveu was trying to help an animal fight an infection. You're asking why we don't pay more attention to birds that already seem better able to survive one. The approaches are different, of course, but both make me wonder how much we still have to learn about the animal's own defenses.
I'd love to get my hands on Neveu's original case notes. Not because I expect to find some forgotten miracle cure, but because I'm genuinely curious about what he observed and how much of that story has survived intact.
That is indeed interesting. I’ve read many old veterinary texts in regards to old therapies prior to the antibiotic era (because of my work with organic dairy cattle). Distemper and Foot and mouth are indeed both viral diseases. And animals can survive both, just like H5N1. It’s possible they wold have survived but it’s also equally as interesting using the magnesium treatment.
Hubert, you're right. Those animals may well have recovered on their own. That's why I'd love to see Neveu's original records.
But here's something you might find interesting, especially with your experience in organic dairy farming.
In 1945, Delbet published L'agriculture et la santé (Agriculture and Health). He even dedicated the book in part to Neveu, a doctor he'd never met.
And he wrote something remarkable:
“No human activity, not even medicine, matters more to health than agriculture.”
Think about that. A surgeon who spent years treating infected soldiers eventually turned his attention to the soil, farming, and the mineral balance of our food.
As you know from experience, even a beautiful green pasture can hide serious mineral imbalances. Excess potassium can interfere with magnesium uptake by plants and its absorption in cattle. Grass tetany is a serious example of what can happen when that balance goes wrong.
That's what fascinates me about Delbet. He saw connections between agriculture and health that medicine and farming still need to take seriously.
With your years of experience, have you encountered pastures that looked perfectly healthy, while the cattle were telling you a different story?
I've been exploring this wider history in my article, The Biological Shield: What Happened to Medicine That Strengthened the Host Instead of Chasing One Pathogen at a Time?
You guys might like to read Dr. Pierre Kory's latest book about water in/on our planet. It meshes completely with what you're finding regarding agriculture. Earth's Living Water - its history, its ruin, and the way back. Pierre Kory, MD, MPA
Elaine, thanks for the recommendation! I haven't read Kory's book yet, but the connection between water, soil, minerals, and health sounds fascinating. Pierre Delbet was exploring similar questions back in 1945.
My research has now taken me to India and Professor Araga Ramesha Rao, who studied magnesium, selenium, and vitamins A and C in an experimental cancer-prevention study in rats in 1990. I'm looking into what happened to that research for my next Biological Shield story.
Have you read Kory's book? I'm curious whether he mentions Delbet or any of that earlier research.
"The peafowl and guinea fowl spend much of their time roaming the property, sleeping in the barn or up in the trees at night. They come begging for treats at the door, wander around as though they own the place, and occasionally express their appreciation by depositing large bird droppings on top of our cars."
FYI, a ring of peafowl were recently convicted of real estate title theft in neighboring West Virginia. The question of whether they really did own the place had previously been a matter for civil courts to decide. In the subsequent criminal proceedings, one peafowl deposited large bird droppings on the judicial bench, and probably came out worse for his insolence in the sentencing phase. Gotta watch'em.
Evolution…God’s “Gain of Function”…adaptation for survival where animals with stronger systems develop into new resistant animals and subsequent less need for proprietary ingredients of the Capitalistic type…
…no wonder they cull entire herds of research ostriches in Canada or mass culling in America
Seems that the last thing they want is naturally occurring resistant offspring of consumer animals 🧐
Repost: Per Dr. Meryl Nass, 166 million birds were culled under Biden. I wrote a few days ago: I find it helpful to begin with the premise that their faux virtue and morality are pretexts for seizing absolute power and control. That they even dare to pretend they're acting in our best interests is disgusting.
Rebel news was on the ground while the Ostrich cull was happening… they were working with the owners pleading for the life of their birds. Rebel filmed everything that transpired and turned it into a documentary. I donated… when the film was done… I couldn’t bear to watch the slaughter. In the middle of the night… they were corralled in a pen… surrounded by bales of hay… and men with automatic guns and night vision slaughtered them… some suffering and living till dawn. Broke my heart then… breaks it now… they were healthy birds with antibodies. … and well loved by their owners.
The answers live within the common sense category. Common sense seems to be the antithesis of what is being done with enormous amounts of money. It's almost as if the government has a gambling addiction. Maybe "almost" is an understatement. The devastation to the farm income, owners and everything else involved is such a waste, let alone the very act of mass slaughter emits terror into the very air we breathe.
Hello Robert.. there were antibodies to the bird flue… yes indeed a whole herd of ostrich that were gunned down by the Canadian government… they had got the flue… and survived… the owners begged for a chance to use their antibodies.. nope… can’t have that. Log into Rebel News… they did a whole documentary about that fiasco…
https://www.malone.news/p/ostriches-executed-for-no-good-reason
Yeah, we’ve written about this extensively
You’ve(Dr. Malone) has hit on a core critique that many agro-ecologists and small-scale farmers share. There are many folks on the Good Doctor's side...
There is a deep asymmetry in how public and private funding is allocated:
Billions flow into high-tech, proprietary lab interventions, while very little supports the systematic study of field-level resilience.
By shifting the lens away from hyper-isolated laboratory models and toward actual operational farms, several critical insights emerge about how birds build resistance under ordinary conditions.
********************************
The Field-Level Blind Spot: What the Labs Miss
When geneticists try to engineer disease resistance in a lab, they typically look for a single "switch"—a specific protein receptor or gene sequence (like ANP32A, a common target for CRISPR research) that they can alter to block the virus.
However, real-world immunity is rarely a single switch. Birds thriving in ordinary, less-industrialized farm environments often rely on a complex web of factors that labs struggle to replicate:
• Polygenic Immunity: Real-world resistance is usually polygenic—meaning it is driven by dozens of minor genetic variations working in tandem across the bird's entire immune system. Because this architecture is incredibly complex and hard to patent, it receives far less corporate research funding than a clean, single-gene edit.
• The Microbiome and Environmental Micro-Dosing: Birds raised on varied terrain, with access to diverse forage, soil, and sunlight, develop vastly different gut and respiratory microbiomes than those raised in sterile, climate-controlled barns. In ordinary farm settings, flocks are continuously exposed to low-pathogenic, mild strains of avian viruses brought in by wild birds. This constant "micro-dosing" can prime their immune systems, giving them a level of adaptive resilience that a lab-raised, pathogen-free chicken completely lacks.
• Epigenetics: Lab studies often ignore epigenetics—how environmental stressors or benefits alter gene expression across generations. A maternal hen that survives environmental challenges passes down specific antibodies and epigenetic markers to her chicks, a natural multi-generational defense mechanism that is severed in industrial hatcheries.
***************************************
If there are birds thriving under ordinary conditions, why isn't the agricultural establishment studying them to scale up solutions?
1. The Conflict with "Maximum Yield"
The primary barrier is that the industrial poultry industry operates on microscopic financial margins. The birds are bred strictly for maximum feed-to-meat conversion rates or extreme egg-laying frequencies.
When researchers observe "thriving" birds on ordinary or diversified farms, those birds are almost always heritage breeds, landraces, or mixed crosses. These birds allocate a significant portion of their biological energy toward maintaining a robust immune system. In the eyes of industrial integrators, that energy is "wasted"—it's energy that isn't being converted into breast meat or daily eggs. The industry has historically been unwilling to accept even a 5% drop in production efficiency in exchange for natural disease resistance.
2. The Data Collection Gap
Because the USDA's default protocol for highly pathogenic avian influenza is immediate eradication, we actually destroy the very data that could save the industry. When a farm is struck by H5N1, the entire flock is culled within 24 to 48 hours.
This means we rarely give nature the chance to show us who would survive. If 95% of a flock dies but 5% possesses a natural genetic immunity, those 5% are culled right along with the rest to satisfy trade regulations. We are actively throwing away the biological roadmap to natural resistance because the regulatory framework doesn’t allow for the observation of survivors.
********************************
Some independent researchers and veterinary ecologists advocate for a shift toward "agro-ecological surveillance." Instead of trying to force a fragile, monoculture bird to survive in a high-density barn through genetic engineering, this approach suggests:
1. Mapping Survivor Flocks: Systematically genotyping small, backyard, or pasture-based flocks that were exposed to wild migratory birds carrying H5N1 but did not succumb to the disease.
2. Decentralized Breeding Hubs: Funding regional breeding hubs that select for robust, all-around health and structural soundness rather than a singular production metric.
3. Rethinking the Biosecurity Paradigm: Moving away from the idea that absolute sterility is the only safety. True safety may lie in biological diversity—both in the genetics of the birds and the ecosystems they live in.
Sources:
https://www.governing.com/policy/killing-166-million-birds-hasnt-stopped-bird-flu-is-there-a-better-way
https://www.facebook.com/animalwelfareinstitute
https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2025-02-26/poultry-culling-hasnt-stopped-h5n1-bird-flu
A farmer friend once said to me regarding field science vs lab science: what is shown in the field can be replicated in the lab, but what is shown in the lab can't necessarily be replicated in the field. Very, very true.
The first tenet of science is OBSERVATION. And while one farmer's observations may not apply across the whole domain of agriculture, if the observation is studied out, especially if a handful of farmers have the same observation, it is a worthy project. Basically a case-series in the medical epidemiologic terminology. Perhaps very low on the worshipped "evidence-based science" paradigm, but one not to be dismissed.
Anyone comes on your property from any government agency you are entitled to:
Ask for ID and be shown that ID.
Read, examine and get copies of any paperwork or relevant laws as to why said officials are there.
Limit the scope of their entry or intrusion.
Have a supervisor respond to the scene.
Exceptions are warrants, fresh pursuit and exigent circumstances.
Be leery of non Police officialdom that enters and demands things. They are probably wrong. As a Sgt. went to extensive and ongoing training about search and seizure. Most officials and many attorneys have no clue what is legal and above board or not.
Still have 13 assorted chickens on our homestead. No one is killing them except my wife or the occasional bird that gets eaten by a coyote.
The worst are civil forfeiture laws imho. Circumventing our fourth amendment entirely
Civil forfeitures are a nuanced game, with specific uses. And yes they do get abused and misused.
It’s legalised theft without due process as I see it. Personally? I have more respect for uniformed police that steal money at gunpoint.
Thank you, excellent advice!
Such good knowledge about rights that very few know. Thank you.
Anything designed by mankind in laboratories is to be questioned. Dr Malone's chickens are fed well and are out in nature; and are healthy. My father raised 5 children without medicine or medical assistance...and we were all here, until a brother took the vax in 2022 in order to travel. I am 92...and don't use any medication. I do use very specific food supplements; not coming from commercial drug stores.
RIGHT ON! I don't play The Doktor Game either. I was so proud to get my AA degree in Medical Assisting more than forty years ago. Working in medical offices and hospitals opened my eyes. I never went back ... so far so good ... I'm 87 and counting.
How about sharing the names and where you get waid food supplements!!! You have some very good genes. So the vax got your brother? Wow. Who CAN we trust?
I remember reading about that when it happened. It sure sounds like someone was protecting a money-laundering operation.
The Malones, I believe, did an article on this as it happened. I sent a donation to the farm to try to help them restock. They never cashed the check.
This is a SICKENING TRUTH that every person in the whole world needs to know about.
This is why we don't let any 'official' organization know about the chickens we may or may not have in the family. The birds are all doing fine. The testing is not really telling you anything meaningful. I feed the outdoor birds (jays, sparrows, whatever flies to my feeders) because I actually DO support wild bird populations in my area.
There are enough invasive predators (house cats) that my neighbors have (and I get it, they love the company and the rodent control), that I try to be the counter balance to the environment and try to keep my native bird populations going strong. We had wildfires this Summer that took out a lot of the forest lands, I think that really drove the jays down to my part of our canyon. I am not worried about H5N1. I have seen this story too many times in my 70 years of biochemical research. Maybe I will be when I am 90 and immune compromised, but I am also good with the good Lord taking me when it's my time. Just sayin'...
As a veterinarian and a backyard flock owner who lives not too far from H5N1 epicenter of Athens, GA, the culling makes me sick to my stomach.
They always throw up one study from Africa in the 2000s that had 100% mortality. Sample size was tiny and they were experimentally infected.
I have layers and we have free roaming games that eat our Georgia ticks. I have lost one or two chickens here and there to respiratory disease, but never had a flock die off or even a total flock illness.
My games are free roaming.....they kill each other occasionally, but they are very healthy.
My layers occasionally have issues because they are not free roaming, but the issues are mild and they all live at least 6 or 7 years with no intervention other than hot pepper flakes.
I think the reasons for any flu issues in commercial operations are due to overcrowding and poor ventilation.....want a recipe for respiratory disease in ANY species? There ya go.
I have never tested any of my birds and never will.
My layers are molting right now, so very few eggs.
The culling is also a racket. This big producers get reimbursed for killing the flock if they have a positive test......so.
Gee, didn’t improvement in overcrowding and sanitation seem to correlate with a reduction in human morbidity and mortality?
yeah.....funny how it all works the same....ain't it?
Is it possible that eating naturally disease resistant food, be it animal or vegetable, would help the consumer of the food become more disease resistant as well?
Mankind lived thousands of years on natural unprocessed food...The Processed Foods have little value...They provide calories and fill the stomach, but actually rob the body of nutrients being digested. For 65 years, i have researched health and nutrition and at 92 I am healthier than I was a 30. I take no medication. Hippocrates, the Father of Medicine, was known for his cures. He prescribed natural food, and said exercise was equally as important as food...so I do almost 2 hours of non-stop walking daily in the fresh air and sunlight. These are things he prescribed. Good health comes from very simple things.
RIGHT ON ... I'm on that path ... hope to continue to be part of your group of really smart old farts.
I admire your dedication to maintaining good health by feeding your body with natural foods containing nutrients we need. Walking in sunshine, fresh air is a major part of longevity. Here’s to many more productive years!
Thank you! I follow Hippocrates, The Father of Medicine, who was known for his cures. He used the word Medicine to mean Food. He said, "Let Food be your medicine; and Medicine be Your Food." How did the Medical Industry come up with toxic lab-created items and calling them medicine? He also said that exercise was equally as important as food. Hippocrates teachings are not taught in Medical Schools...Guess its not interested in cures!
During the course of giving scores of talks to organic farmers and veterinary groups, I have always said that the basis to immunity is sunshine, fresh air, clean water, dry bedding and species-appropriate food. With that (and not being crammed into barracks by the thousands), the immune system can function as God intended.
Another great article by y’all. The question of why not use common sense animal husbandry (in terms of breeding for resistance) versus glamorous animal science (genetic editing, genetic vaccines, etc) is simple: money. There is no money for companies to make in animal husbandry (well, not much) compared to the billions in the pharma-university-regulatory complex. I know you guys know that but that is simply the truth. It’s the p<.05 crowd versus common sense.
The other thing is that even though we certainly could and should breed for resistance, cramming thousands of birds into industrial poultry houses creates very fragile “eco-systems”, where people have to shower-in and suit up to go in (like huge hog houses, too). Basically, the USDA is most interested in creating the cheapest food possible for the most people with science that worships the mighty p<.05 and rewards companies with grants that can patent products to support such systems.
American ag has become dependent on science that supports essentially well-fed and well-medicated concentration camps.
Animal husbandry is for the people. Animal science is for the companies.
That was exactly my take, common sense.
Thanks for yet another readable, article that shares important information. Your sharing of the knowledge you researched and live with is a gift of caring for mankind.
When I get my homestead I’ll be answering the door with a shotgun.
When you crowd 10,000 chickens into a confined space without sun light and the chickens do not have personal space, their immune system goes to h*ll in a hand basket! The clever design of mass production of chickens and eggs is the root cause. So, susceptibility to infections such as bird flu is the result. Change the farming practices and the problem is solved.
If only our wish would be their command!
Poultry and Governments
Wanton destruction. At the top of my list was the evil destruction of a population of ostriches in Canada. Apparenty recovered and healthy. With several viable options.
Development of plants by breeding has been encouraged over the years. Why not birds/chickens? Is the answer the pharma opportunities? Natures answers benefit the birds and their owners. Industry answers benefit corporations and investors. In the end, who shoulders the impacts and costs - the farmers, customers and the birds.
A part of my higher education was devoted to animal husbandry. Even chicken breeding and management. My experiences at the zoo in the bird dept never touched on diseases, nor wild bird caused infections.
I couldn't be more in favor of studying, selecting and pursuing breeding that occasions disease resistance. As a taxpayer I vote for this type of use of our moneys!
Thank you muchly for covering this valuable discussion again!
We have fed wild birds for well over a 50 yr span at 3 different locations in Texas and never been diagnosed with bird flu. Testing our serum for that bug might be interesting tho.
Your article about breeding chickens that can survive bird flu reminded me of an old story from France. It's something I've been looking into lately.
During World War I, a French surgeon named Pierre Delbet was treating soldiers with infected wounds. This was long before antibiotics, when a serious infection could easily cost a man his life. Delbet became interested in magnesium chloride and its effects on white blood cells. He wondered whether doctors could do more to help the body fight back.
Years later, another French physician, Auguste Neveu, came across his work. Neveu had served as a medical officer in the French Navy and graduated at the top of his medical class in Bordeaux.
In the 1930s, Neveu began trying out Delbet's ideas in practice, including on sick animals. Two cases appear in the old accounts: a dog suffering from distemper and a calf with foot-and-mouth disease. Both reportedly recovered after being given magnesium chloride. Neveu was particularly insistent about starting treatment at the very first signs of illness.
Did magnesium chloride actually save those animals? I wish we knew. Those accounts alone can't tell us.
But I find the story fascinating, especially when I think about your chickens.
Neveu was trying to help an animal fight an infection. You're asking why we don't pay more attention to birds that already seem better able to survive one. The approaches are different, of course, but both make me wonder how much we still have to learn about the animal's own defenses.
I'd love to get my hands on Neveu's original case notes. Not because I expect to find some forgotten miracle cure, but because I'm genuinely curious about what he observed and how much of that story has survived intact.
That is indeed interesting. I’ve read many old veterinary texts in regards to old therapies prior to the antibiotic era (because of my work with organic dairy cattle). Distemper and Foot and mouth are indeed both viral diseases. And animals can survive both, just like H5N1. It’s possible they wold have survived but it’s also equally as interesting using the magnesium treatment.
Hubert, you're right. Those animals may well have recovered on their own. That's why I'd love to see Neveu's original records.
But here's something you might find interesting, especially with your experience in organic dairy farming.
In 1945, Delbet published L'agriculture et la santé (Agriculture and Health). He even dedicated the book in part to Neveu, a doctor he'd never met.
And he wrote something remarkable:
“No human activity, not even medicine, matters more to health than agriculture.”
Think about that. A surgeon who spent years treating infected soldiers eventually turned his attention to the soil, farming, and the mineral balance of our food.
As you know from experience, even a beautiful green pasture can hide serious mineral imbalances. Excess potassium can interfere with magnesium uptake by plants and its absorption in cattle. Grass tetany is a serious example of what can happen when that balance goes wrong.
That's what fascinates me about Delbet. He saw connections between agriculture and health that medicine and farming still need to take seriously.
With your years of experience, have you encountered pastures that looked perfectly healthy, while the cattle were telling you a different story?
I've been exploring this wider history in my article, The Biological Shield: What Happened to Medicine That Strengthened the Host Instead of Chasing One Pathogen at a Time?
https://arturkolski.substack.com/p/biologiczna-tarcza-co-stao-sie-z
You guys might like to read Dr. Pierre Kory's latest book about water in/on our planet. It meshes completely with what you're finding regarding agriculture. Earth's Living Water - its history, its ruin, and the way back. Pierre Kory, MD, MPA
Elaine, thanks for the recommendation! I haven't read Kory's book yet, but the connection between water, soil, minerals, and health sounds fascinating. Pierre Delbet was exploring similar questions back in 1945.
My research has now taken me to India and Professor Araga Ramesha Rao, who studied magnesium, selenium, and vitamins A and C in an experimental cancer-prevention study in rats in 1990. I'm looking into what happened to that research for my next Biological Shield story.
Have you read Kory's book? I'm curious whether he mentions Delbet or any of that earlier research.
"The peafowl and guinea fowl spend much of their time roaming the property, sleeping in the barn or up in the trees at night. They come begging for treats at the door, wander around as though they own the place, and occasionally express their appreciation by depositing large bird droppings on top of our cars."
FYI, a ring of peafowl were recently convicted of real estate title theft in neighboring West Virginia. The question of whether they really did own the place had previously been a matter for civil courts to decide. In the subsequent criminal proceedings, one peafowl deposited large bird droppings on the judicial bench, and probably came out worse for his insolence in the sentencing phase. Gotta watch'em.
A brighter day after walking to check on the welfare of mama Canada goose who's wing is useless (her mate is sticking!) and reading this!! ( ◠‿◠ )
Evolution…God’s “Gain of Function”…adaptation for survival where animals with stronger systems develop into new resistant animals and subsequent less need for proprietary ingredients of the Capitalistic type…
…no wonder they cull entire herds of research ostriches in Canada or mass culling in America
Seems that the last thing they want is naturally occurring resistant offspring of consumer animals 🧐
Repost: Per Dr. Meryl Nass, 166 million birds were culled under Biden. I wrote a few days ago: I find it helpful to begin with the premise that their faux virtue and morality are pretexts for seizing absolute power and control. That they even dare to pretend they're acting in our best interests is disgusting.
https://merylnass.substack.com/p/whats-up-with-bird-flu
Rebel news was on the ground while the Ostrich cull was happening… they were working with the owners pleading for the life of their birds. Rebel filmed everything that transpired and turned it into a documentary. I donated… when the film was done… I couldn’t bear to watch the slaughter. In the middle of the night… they were corralled in a pen… surrounded by bales of hay… and men with automatic guns and night vision slaughtered them… some suffering and living till dawn. Broke my heart then… breaks it now… they were healthy birds with antibodies. … and well loved by their owners.
The people who ordered that need to be held accountable
The answers live within the common sense category. Common sense seems to be the antithesis of what is being done with enormous amounts of money. It's almost as if the government has a gambling addiction. Maybe "almost" is an understatement. The devastation to the farm income, owners and everything else involved is such a waste, let alone the very act of mass slaughter emits terror into the very air we breathe.